Earn 1k coins for your honest song review

grainy

Super Idol
Early Supporters
Posts
325
Reaction score
417
Points
5,220
Location
here
Plus Coins
⨭584,161
Listen to a Hebe Tien song or cover and review it honestly and I'll give you 1k.
- bonus 500 coins if it's a favourite of mine
- bonus 500 coins if I like your review.

Post the link to the video together with your review.
I don't really care if you like or don't like the song, please just say what you think.
I just want to be able to tell that you listened to it - she's my favourite singer and I just want to share her music, that's all.

Additional rules:
- this ends when I've given out 50k, or on the 22nd at 8pm GST
- you cannot review A Little Happiness
- you cannot review a song someone else has reviewed before.
- no required review length, it can be one line or an essay, so long as I can tell you did listen.
- you can review up to 5 songs if you so wish
- you might find more of her songs if you enter the name 田馥甄
- i might not check back on this thread until the deadline
 

abra

PD-nim
Early Supporters
Posts
1,413
Reaction score
944
Points
9,420
Location
Social distancing
Plus Coins
⨭580,570
If anyone's wondering how to find her songs, I'll post some Youtube links:

Hebe Tien playlist (most of her MVs):


Album playlists:
To Hebe


My Love


Insignificance


Everyday


Her most recent songs can be found on her official YT page

 

OutroTearTheFirst

gasppepe
Second Place HoE
Top Ten Elite
VIP+
Outro and Nara
Posts
2,456
Reaction score
13,583
Points
56,320
Location
On a picnic with gasppepe eating nugget peepo
Plus Coins
⨭2,928,069
  • Certified Shawol
  • Certified ReVeluv
  • Valentines Award
  • Certified ARMY (Alternative)

Ok so when the MAN started to sing I was like, “ huh? I thought this was a woman?” But then eventually she started to sing as well lmao. I really enjoy the parts when she enters the song because the song starts to have a nice beat to it, as opposed to the beginning. I like that the bridge takes us back to how the song started, with just a piano. I’m not in love with it, but I do find it very pretty. If I were rating it out of ten it would get a seven.​
 

Polaris_Tae

无感 SOTY
Social Media
Donor
Early Supporters
Posts
1,308
Reaction score
2,349
Points
22,620
Location
SNS PR Overlord
Plus Coins
⨭653,000
  • Certified NEXT Fan
  • Lan Wangji
  • WayV
  • NEXT's Zhengting
Wuji is still my SOTY but she sounds nice, kind like some of the stuff that my mom used to listen to but 10 x better bc she seems to be able to combine easy listening with heavy hitting beats such as heavy drum solos. (I listened to Stay)




This is Wuji btw:


 
Last edited:

Nayeonnie

Lesbian ♡ Gg Stan♡ 2nd Gen Princess ♡ Brazil
Posts
82
Reaction score
49
Points
370
Location
B r a z i l
Plus Coins
⨭165,905
  • Certified Pink Panda
  • Certified Ujung
  • Certified Miracle (Alternative)
The song is a pretty ballad and then gets a tiny bit faster but still a ballad and it's pretty nice to chill to. It's so emotional though, and I found the MV so sad. Her voice is amazing and she's real pretty but I already knew that lol. I already like Mandopop and kinda knew her but not this song.


 

Belrockangel

Senpai
Early Supporters
Posts
2,980
Reaction score
1,484
Points
9,370
Location
Somewhere over the rainbow, waiting for SMNGG
Plus Coins
⨭786,145
  • Certified ReVeluv
  • Certified NCTzen
  • Red Velvet's Wendy
  • NCT's Renjun


About the video: i like the colors and the vibe, she is beautiful and i LOVE the eyes makeup on min 1:14.


About the song: She has a pleassant voice. It's a little repetitive wich is not bad, but doesn't have anything catchy or memorable. It's not my type of song, but it isn't a bad song: i f i'm listening a playlist and i'm unable to change to other song, i wouldn't matter. It's an "ok" song.
(I really like the guitar chords at the end)
Edit: i didn't realize it has eng subs....:facepalm: But i like the fact that the lyrics are positive and goes well with the vibe of the video.
 
Last edited:

grainy

Super Idol
Early Supporters
Posts
325
Reaction score
417
Points
5,220
Location
here
Plus Coins
⨭584,161
Ok so when the MAN started to sing I was like, “ huh? I thought this was a woman?” But then eventually she started to sing as well lmao. I really enjoy the parts when she enters the song because the song starts to have a nice beat to it, as opposed to the beginning. I like that the bridge takes us back to how the song started, with just a piano. I’m not in love with it, but I do find it very pretty. If I were rating it out of ten it would get a seven.​
I was surprised when I first heard it too. This is the only collab song on her 4 albums so far actually! Bit surprised you picked this one :) 1.5k for you because I can tell you were paying attention to the song too. It's not a favourite of mine.

Wuji is still my SOTY but she sounds nice, kind like some of the stuff that my mom used to listen to but 10 x better bc she seems to be able to combine easy listening with heavy hitting beats such as heavy drum solos. (I listened to Stay)

This is Wuji btw:
Stay is interesting because it's a live recorded song actually, she was toying with a completely live recorded series before leaving her company. I'm glad you picked that one, but 1k for you because it's still not a favourite of mine.

Seems you like more historical songs? Or Wang Yibo and Xiao Zhan?

The song is a pretty ballad and then gets a tiny bit faster but still a ballad and it's pretty nice to chill to. It's so emotional though, and I found the MV so sad. Her voice is amazing and she's real pretty but I already knew that lol. I already like Mandopop and kinda knew her but not this song.
This song was released in 2010 actually, that's understandable! It was the song that really sealed her place as a solo artiste, coming from such a famous idol group (S.H.E). It's her solo debut title. The style was different enough that for a while some people were actually confused by the "this newly debuted Tian Fuzhen looks a lot like Hebe" jokes at the time. 1k coins for you. It's not a current favourite.

amazong 10/10 would stream on twitter :shablob:
I agree but I can't give you coins lmao

About the video: i like the colors and the vibe, she is beautiful and i LOVE the eyes makeup on min 1:14.


About the song: She has a pleassant voice. It's a little repetitive wich is not bad, but doesn't have anything catchy or memorable. It's not my type of song, but it isn't a bad song: i f i'm listening a playlist and i'm unable to change to other song, i wouldn't matter. It's an "ok" song.
(I really like the guitar chords at the end)
Edit: i didn't realize it has eng subs....:facepalm: But i like the fact that the lyrics are positive and goes well with the vibe of the video.
1.5k for you, because I can tell you were paying attention to the song/mv! It's indeed fairly flat structurally but that's the slightly restrained vibe she's going for I believe. It's not a favourite song.


You're all welcome to review another song, of course - and I'll give you a hint for the bonus 500 - a few of my favourite songs are OSTs, and even if a song isn't my favourite, the live version might be a favourite live version, especially the ones from this year.
 
Last edited:

Lemon Detox

🥚🐣🐥🐤🦅
Early Supporters
Posts
1,382
Reaction score
1,386
Points
8,220
Location
Wincity
Plus Coins
⨭75,925
  • NCT's Winwin
  • NCT's WinRen
  • NCT's WinKun
  • Jing Boran
I've heard of Hebe from S.H.E but never really stopped to listen to her music before, until I had to listen to this song once for a game and I was so impressed. Her voice is really beautiful and soothing. I love how the instrumental progresses through the song, starting with the guitar and then adding drums, a glockenspiel-like instrument (?) and finally synths. The lyrics are so lovely too




Also not a review, just want to promote her OST with Jing Boran for Beauty and The Beast! :heartpar:

 

grainy

Super Idol
Early Supporters
Posts
325
Reaction score
417
Points
5,220
Location
here
Plus Coins
⨭584,161
I've heard of Hebe from S.H.E but never really stopped to listen to her music before, until I had to listen to this song once for a game and I was so impressed. Her voice is really beautiful and soothing. I love how the instrumental progresses through the song, starting with the guitar and then adding drums, a glockenspiel-like instrument (?) and finally synths. The lyrics are so lovely too
Also not a review, just want to promote her OST with Jing Boran for Beauty and The Beast! :heartpar:
Because of Blue during one of those playlist games? :omgwhat: i love ha
Yes I find her voice really soothing too! :) I think that's why I listen to her so much really, especially when I'm working.
This song is actually a cover, refreshed for a movie OST. I enjoyed the original, but this more modern version I like maybe a bit more. As a fan, I also appreciate that it's in the same style as LOVE, with the marching beat.

you can explore her discography/covers for coins if you want haha, you can review 4 more if you like :).
1.5k coins because I can tell you listened.
Neither songs are in my top 5 favourite list.
.25k bonus cause I felt happy seeing your review.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Lemon Detox

Lemon Detox

🥚🐣🐥🐤🦅
Early Supporters
Posts
1,382
Reaction score
1,386
Points
8,220
Location
Wincity
Plus Coins
⨭75,925
  • NCT's Winwin
  • NCT's WinRen
  • NCT's WinKun
  • Jing Boran
Because of Blue during one of those playlist games? :omgwhat: i love ha
Yes I find her voice really soothing too! :) I think that's why I listen to her so much really, especially when I'm working.
This song is actually a cover, refreshed for a movie OST. I enjoyed the original, but this more modern version I like maybe a bit more. As a fan, I also appreciate that it's in the same style as LOVE, with the marching beat.

you can explore her discography/covers for coins if you want haha, you can review 4 more if you like :).
1.5k coins because I can tell you listened.
Neither songs are in my top 5 favourite list.
.25k bonus cause I felt happy seeing your review.
Yes, it was her who submitted it!
Ohh I had no idea it was a cover. It suits her voice pretty well though!
 

grainy

Super Idol
Early Supporters
Posts
325
Reaction score
417
Points
5,220
Location
here
Plus Coins
⨭584,161
Yes, it was her who submitted it!
Ohh I had no idea it was a cover. It suits her voice pretty well though!
Ay! I think her best quality is that she manages to make all the songs she covers sound like hers... and to some extent I actually like some covers more than I like her original songs