[KPKF] What's your ideal number of members for idol groups?

Astro

Idol
Early Supporters
Posts
1,212
Reaction score
766
Points
10,120
Location
Wonderland
Plus Coins
⨭653,550


Pann: What's your ideal number of members for idol groups?

1. [+236, -6] If there's more than 10 members, it stops me from entering the fandom.

2. [+202, -7] For all-fans, 5 is nice. It's not too little or too much.

3. [+186, -10] 7 for me. The formation is pretty and there's good chemistry between the members.

4. [+62, -2] 5 for me. The part division is nice and the stage formation is pretty, too.

5. [+57, -1] I stan a 5-member group and it's perfect. But if there's a member missing, the choreography looks really empty. I think that's the con.

6. [+51, -1] 6 for me. I like even numbers and I like how they can divide into pairs of 2 for games and reality shows.

7. [+27, -1] 5. I used to wonder how people could stan huge groups but now I'm an all-fan of one ㅋㅋ Let me cry as a NCTzen.

8. [+24, -0] I'm an Ujung and I really like 13 members. My bias takes a big part in the group but the stage formation is so pretty and the choreography looks amazing. Their visuals are diverse and there's a lot of personalities, so it's nicely loud all the time ㅎㅎ Of course, the 10-member promotions aren't too bad, either.

9. [+22, -0] My fandom experienced 12, 11, 10, 9, 8, and 7...

10. [+19, -3] I've stanned only big groups so I lost the standard for "too much" ㅋㅋ I'm a Carat and it's not like I have to give up some things because there's too many members. I like seeing the members playing together.

11. [+18, -0] Even if we decide this, the group looks lacking once there's a few members missing. I'd watch V app and be like, "wait, that's it?" I'm a NCTzen.

12. [+17, -5] A lot of talented groups are 4 or 5. Bigbang, Sistar, pre-TVXQ, SHINee, Mamamoo, etc.

13. [+16, -1] I like 4 the most because I have trouble memorizing all the members' names ㅋㅋㅋㅋ Blackpink, Brown Eyed Girls, Mamamoo, etc.

Source
 
  • Love
Reactions: sandwich and MVSica

sm maid

Proud Soomanie
Moderator
Posts
1,757
Reaction score
3,947
Points
17,070
Location
lsm's office
Plus Coins
⨭46,350
11. [+18, -0] Even if we decide this, the group looks lacking once there's a few members missing. I'd watch V app and be like, "wait, that's it?" I'm a NCTzen.

lmfaooo yes I feel this
 

MVSica

✨🐻Ujung🛰️✨
Donor
Posts
3,835
Reaction score
4,831
Points
33,920
Location
Ujung Palace
Plus Coins
⨭65,033
:fab:

8. [+24, -0] I'm an Ujung and I really like 13 members. My bias takes a big part in the group but the stage formation is so pretty and the choreography looks amazing. Their visuals are diverse and there's a lot of personalities, so it's nicely loud all the time ㅎㅎ Of course, the 10-member promotions aren't too bad, either.
 
  • Love
Reactions: UMJI MOODS
Y

Yeddong

Guest
4 to 6 members, that's my ideal number of members. If I were CEO of an agency, I would definitely debut groups of no more than 6 members.
 
  • Love
Reactions: UMJI MOODS

Grape Soda

🍇🍇🍇
Posts
908
Reaction score
963
Points
4,370
Location
Earth
Plus Coins
⨭1,133,725
I'm a carat soooo of course I cant say I dont like big groups but groups like nct who keep adding members and units, I cant follow them.
 

BianTwo

Girl Groups Supporter
Early Supporters
Posts
3,015
Reaction score
2,108
Points
10,220
Location
Garden Flover
Plus Coins
⨭463,540
7 members is my ideal number of members. Enough to find a bias, to create some complexe choreographies and if one or two members were missing you can still perform

Over 8-9 members if can be difficult for the public to follow

4-5 members you better take really care of them because if one or two are missing it's going to be empty. But since they aren't many people can recognize them easily, so more exposure, more line, etc.
 

SageWren

The Genre is BTS
Donor
Posts
729
Reaction score
553
Points
7,120
Location
Hope World
Plus Coins
⨭553,095
5-7 is my ideal. If a group is bigger than that they (the company) need to make sure to give alot of individual focus to each member or have subunits such as SVT did/does, otherwise it's just a wall of people. Both NCT and WJSN struggle with this problem, and its worsened in NCT's case since only a select few get any focus.
 

Some

~
Early Supporters
Posts
6,552
Reaction score
1,976
Points
26,220
Location
Somewhere
Plus Coins
⨭526,450
Who's cares the more the merreir i don't understand why people obsess over numbers who cares if they are 3 or 20 as long as you got good people good music you should just sit down and be blessed why is that so hard ?
 

Pyron

The Blue Lightning
Donor
Early Supporters
Posts
1,107
Reaction score
93,430
Points
25,970
Location
Warrior's Village
Plus Coins
⨭4,365,980
I'd say 4 to 7, but again I like some of the big groups like Twice and WJSN.

I don't think the size matters that much. It matters if we go for some logical/rational logistics, but almost nobody will be. Most ardent fans stan just a handful inside a group anyway (which is perfectly normal) if not just one member. If it's 2 or 100 it won't matter in reality.
 

Tommie

🍨
Donor
Posts
3,685
Reaction score
16,761
Points
52,920
Plus Coins
⨭808,900
My maximum is 7. I can't keep up with groups that have more than 7 members now I'm that I'm getting old.
:sejeongcry: