SF9's Official Badge Voting Thread!!! [LOOKING FOR NEW OP]

Bchip

ᴀ ʜ ɢ ᴀ s ᴇ Events VIP+
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
6,586
Reaction score
12,747
Points
72,420
Location
☁️
Plus Coins
⨭1,741,650
Pronouns
He/Him
A few suggestions:

Chani:
Chani-1.png
Chani-2.png
Chani-3.png

Original: x, x, x

Rowoon:
Rowoon-5.png
Rowoon-1.png
Rowoon-2.png
Rowoon-3.png
Rowoon-4.png
Rowoon-6.png

Original: x, x, x, x, x, x

Taeyang:
Taeyang-1.png
Taeyang-2.png

Original: x, x

Rowoon's #3 might need recoloring, but i can fix it if necessary.
 

Panda

VIP+ Early Supporters
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
13,434
Reaction score
22,488
Points
62,520
Plus Coins
⨭3,908,941
This is the fixed mocks
If there's anything that's still not OK then please ask Award Team to fix them for me :sip:

The other Youngbin badge was approved and the Inseong one was scraped..and theses are fixed ones I will send them to get approved after the suggestions close~
F2ddToL.png
UWkHcV1.png
 

Panda

VIP+ Early Supporters
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
13,434
Reaction score
22,488
Points
62,520
Plus Coins
⨭3,908,941
@paradise.mp3 @MicrowavedTea

The suggestion phase for Zuho, Rowoon, Taeyang, Hwiyoung & Chani has ended, I've sent all the badges for approval.


To Kill time I'll now start the voting phase for the group badge~

Since we have only 5 badges...You can vote for 1 badge only!!
1
2
3
4
5
JdslBgq.png
RWpr5ma.png
D9kvB3N.png
GohJeXO.png
tAqZuPM.png
 
Last edited:

Panda

VIP+ Early Supporters
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
13,434
Reaction score
22,488
Points
62,520
Plus Coins
⨭3,908,941
@paradise.mp3 @MicrowavedTea @Bchip

This is the Pre-approval team's feedback!


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Youngbin:
-
Accepted:
fQNhZkV.png


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Dawon:
- Needs fixing:
the shadows are a bit strong, he is a bit yellow and needs to be centered better
F2ddToL.png


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Zuho:
- Needs fixing:
1)
shadows too strong and looks too LQ
2) is a bit pale and yellow, needs recoloring since he blends too much
3) is too pale and dull

Bg32FnG.png


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Rowoon:
- Needs Fixing:
1)
is too orange/yellow; also needs to be more zoomed out
2) needs a bit of contrast and looks a bit LQ
3) position of the head is too strong + is too bright
4) is too red + needs to be centered better
5) is too yellow, needs to be more zoomed out
6) is too blue and pale; also needs to be centered better
"look impossible to edit tbh so I would discard them"
7) needs to be centered better
8) needs contrast and darkening and a bit of vibrance

bbuAB6A.png


- Would get fixed if they won:
1)
would need more vibrance but can pass (and if needed we can fix it if it wins)
ihjkPbL.png


2) is a bit pale and dark; we can fix it if it wins tbh
ilhMSX5.png


- Accepted:
xEdg70x.png


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Taeyang:

- Need fixing:
1)
is too pale, needs vibrance
2) is too blue and shadows
"I would discard it tbh it looks impossible to edit"
3) is too bright and a bit pale; needs contrast and darkening
KDsvZ85.png


- Discarded: is too dark and pale; also the hand covers all his mouth so that's a no
BmjWj7j.png


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hwiyoung:

- Needs fixing:
1)
looks too LQ and too edited
2) needs a bit of vibrance and darkening
3) needs a bit of sharpening since he is a bit blurry and recoloring because he is a bit greenish
FaOv3ou.png


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chani:

- Needs fixing:
1)
needs recoloring and a bit of contrast
2) needs a bit of vibrance since he is kinda pale
3) is too pale and dark
4) is too magenta + shadows are a bit strong

XCD3FJt.png


- Accepted:
FblwA6H.png

 
Last edited:

Bchip

ᴀ ʜ ɢ ᴀ s ᴇ Events VIP+
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
6,586
Reaction score
12,747
Points
72,420
Location
☁️
Plus Coins
⨭1,741,650
Pronouns
He/Him
I'll try to do some fixing later. And i'll never get this "center" thing. Some award team members say the face should be centralized and others say the picture should be centralized, like :iwillfightyou:
 

Panda

VIP+ Early Supporters
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
13,434
Reaction score
22,488
Points
62,520
Plus Coins
⨭3,908,941
I'll try to do some fixing later. And i'll never get this "center" thing. Some award team members say the face should be centralized and others say the picture should be centralized, like :iwillfightyou:
Same tbh :TzuyuKek:

Also do you want to try to fix the one they advised to discard?
 

Bchip

ᴀ ʜ ɢ ᴀ s ᴇ Events VIP+
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
6,586
Reaction score
12,747
Points
72,420
Location
☁️
Plus Coins
⨭1,741,650
Pronouns
He/Him
Same tbh :TzuyuKek:

Also do you want to try to fix the one they advised to discard?
I can try, but i don't mind discard it. I usually like to suggest a lot of badges just so we can have lots of options, but that one is not really my favorite anyway.
 

Panda

VIP+ Early Supporters
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
13,434
Reaction score
22,488
Points
62,520
Plus Coins
⨭3,908,941
I can try, but i don't mind discard it. I usually like to suggest a lot of badges just so we can have lots of options, but that one is not really my favorite anyway.
I guess...I'll discard them then since I don't want you to spend too much time on fixing badges~
 

Bchip

ᴀ ʜ ɢ ᴀ s ᴇ Events VIP+
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
6,586
Reaction score
12,747
Points
72,420
Location
☁️
Plus Coins
⨭1,741,650
Pronouns
He/Him
I guess...I'll discard them then since I don't want you to spend too much time on fixing badges~
Oh thank you, but no worries. That don't take too much time tbh. And if i don't post anything by tomorrow, feel free to @ me again bc i can't do it rn and i might forget bc that's me :darkkermit:
 

Panda

VIP+ Early Supporters
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
13,434
Reaction score
22,488
Points
62,520
Plus Coins
⨭3,908,941
Oh thank you, but no worries. That don't take too much time tbh. And if i don't post anything by tomorrow, feel free to @ me again bc i can't do it rn and i might forget bc that's me :darkkermit:
No need to rush, I myself won't post until a week or so just to give time for everyone~
 

Bchip

ᴀ ʜ ɢ ᴀ s ᴇ Events VIP+
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
6,586
Reaction score
12,747
Points
72,420
Location
☁️
Plus Coins
⨭1,741,650
Pronouns
He/Him
@Bchip do you have any mocks you want to post?
I forgot just like i predicted lol. I'm gonna fix some of them till tomorrow before noon (kst). Is this ok?
@Bchip do you have any mocks you want to post?
I forgot just like i predicted lol. I'm gonna fix some of them till tomorrow before noon (kst). Is this ok?
 

Panda

VIP+ Early Supporters
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
13,434
Reaction score
22,488
Points
62,520
Plus Coins
⨭3,908,941
I forgot just like i predicted lol. I'm gonna fix some of them till tomorrow before noon (kst). Is this ok?

I forgot just like i predicted lol. I'm gonna fix some of them till tomorrow before noon (kst). Is this ok?
It's okay~ take your time :heartublob:
 

Bchip

ᴀ ʜ ɢ ᴀ s ᴇ Events VIP+
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
6,586
Reaction score
12,747
Points
72,420
Location
☁️
Plus Coins
⨭1,741,650
Pronouns
He/Him
I didn't know what type of centering they want bc the orgianl seems pretty centered for me so i did two for Rowoon's . Lol

MOD1-Rowoon.png
MOD2-Rowoon.png


Chani's:

Chani-3.png
/
MOD2-Chani.png

Chani-2.png
/
MOD1-Chani.png


The rest was discarded.
 
Top Bottom