◈ the official SHINee badge voting thread 2020 ◈ status: Finished!

[Frandae]

Hello, and welcome to the official SHINee badge voting thread for Award Season 2020!​

No fantaken images. To protect the content creators rights as well as ourselves fantaken images are not allowed to be used as badges.
Only HQ pictures. For quality purposes. The higher quality, the better an image will look as a badge.
No heavily edited images. The more edited, the worse the quality becomes overall.
No extreme contrast, highlighted colors, or super light/dark images. They just don't look good when sized down.
Face should be centered. For aesthetic purposes.
Logos should only be used for groups & are not allowed for individuals (in most cases). We understand some artists are very difficult to find pictures of and will deal with that on a case by case basis.
Only screenshots from Music Videos, CFs and official content are allowed. If you're unsure what falls under this rule, please don't hesitate to ask on our ask thread.
Instagram Pictures. Selfies are not allowed, however, pictures taken by someone else are allowed (examples of such: here, here, here or here). Still, keep in mind that these have to meet all the other guidelines as well.
Profiles can be used, as well as some object coverage is allowed. Face coverage isn't totally ruled out but the more you can see of the artist the better. Profiles are OK if we can clearly tell who the artist is.
Derp faces / Exaggerated facial expressions / Unrecognizable. These will not be allowed, badges are not to be meme-like or anything that is out of the ordinary/unpleasant, such as: frowning, crying, etc. We will also not be allowing badges that look weird and in which people look unrecognizable - regardless of it being an official picture.
Zooms. Any mocks found to be too zoomed in or zoomed out will need to be readjusted, as all badges must be able to resized down to 74x74 properly. In the event a mock does not pass crop standards, it will need to be readjusted until our quality standards are met.
Pre-Approval of badges. We ask that all OP’s submit their round 1 mocks to be pre-approved by an Awards member in the appropriate thread. This is to avoid badges that are not up to standards from making it to later rounds and dividing votes from other badges. That being said, we still reserve the right to veto any badge that we feel does not follow the rules by the final crop (this is especially relevant in crop rounds).
Final submission. The Awards team reserves the right to re-do a mock if we feel they are not in accordance to all the aforementioned rules.
OP rules:
No material older than 2018.
All current badges will be included in final voting.
Badge holders will be given a double vote in both preliminary and final votings. However, you must have claimed the badge before October 4th to be counted.

Timezone: GMT+1, all rounds will begin and end at 11:59pm
suggestions for members + group badge:
> oct. 28 - nov. 2nd
pre-approval:
>nov. 3rd - 5th
final voting:
> nov. 5th - nov. 8th
alternative badge voting:
> nov. 7th - nov. 10th
Deadline: November 11th

group | onew | jonghyun | key | minho | taemin

If you would like to be notified when a new round begins, please let me know and I can add you to the tag list!

 

[Frandae]

Username: Frandae
Original photo: x x x x x
Mocks:

 

[larme]

Username: Larme
Original photo: x, x
Mocks:

 

[Frandae]

Badges have been approved! Now we'll proceed with final voting!

To vote; fill the following form:

Username:
Keeper for:
Group:
Onew:
Jonghyun:
Key:
Minho:
Taemin:

Keepers will have double votes! You can vote until November 8th 23:59 CEST!

 

[Frandae]

Username: Frandae
Keeper for: Group, Minho
Group: 1
Onew: 1
Jonghyun: 1
Key: 1
Minho: 1
Taemin: 1

 

[Chiharu]

Username: Chiharu
Keeper for: none
Group: 1
Onew: 1
Jonghyun: 2
Key: 1
Minho: 1
Taemin: 2

 

[with*one]

username: with*one
keeper for: n/a
group: 1
onew: 1
jonghyun: 2
key: 1
minho: 1
taemin: 1

 

[OutroTearTheFirst]

Username: OutroTearTheFirst
Keeper for: Group
Group: 2
Onew: 2
Jonghyun: 2
Key: 1
Minho: 2
Taemin: 1

 

[miatheikonic]

Username: miatheikonic
Keeper for: group
Group: 1
Onew: 1
Jonghyun: 1
Key: 1
Minho: 1
Taemin: 1

 

[Frandae]

Just realized there is an option to add an alternative badge for group! Since SHINee didn't have one in the system, we can add one!

Since there is only two suggestions right now (newest suggestion and current one), the alternative badge will be one of those two no matter what so we can just directly vote via poll; I opened the poll now to save time (since I doubt we will have time later)

You can vote there to decide if we'll have one of the badges as alternative no matter what the winner is!

Poll will be up until November 10th 13:30 GMT+1!​

 

[Apollo]

Username: Apollo
Keeper for: N/A
Group:2
Onew:2
Jonghyun:1
Key:1
Minho:1
Taemin:1

 

[Lilac]

Username: Nara
Keeper for: none
Group: 1
Onew: 1
Jonghyun: 1
Key: 2
Minho: 1
Taemin: 1

 

[Frandae]

Voting just finished and we have our new badges! Results under spoiler tag! (Keepers votes are bolded)

Spoiler

I'll submit these in the next minutes since we don't have enough time for wildcard/editing round; hope you all like the new badges!

Poll for alternative badge (that will be #2, the current one) is still up until the 10th at 13:30 GMT+1!

Thanks for voting!​

 

[Frandae]

Sorry for the delay; something came up at last minute and I had to take care of it!

The voting to see if we get an alternative badge for Group badge (Certified Shawol) just ended and we have the results! (screenshot under spoiler tag!)

Spoiler

Which means that #2, the current badge, will be the alternative badge! I'll go and submit it in the next few minutes!

And with this, we are done with SHINee badges in this Awards Season, thank you so much to everyone who participated and I hope you all enjoy the new badges! See ya!​