[NB] JYP reveals Mina won't be joining Twice for their promos, bans questions about Kang Daniel at comeback showcase

[Kami]

Article: JYP reps, "Twice Mina will not be participating in comeback" (official)'

Source: Star News via Naver

1. [+1,237, -148] Mina-ya, I'll be waiting... and what suddenly happened to Jihyo ㅠㅠ I hope the 'Feel Special' showcase ends well

2. [+513, -74] Mina-ya!! It's fine!! We can wait until whenever!! Don't get sick and eat all your meals, let's see you soon ♥

3. [+362, -35] I trust that the other members will fill Mina's spot. Mina, just focus on recovering your health. Let's do well, Twice!!

4. [+318, -38] Kids, don't get sick ㅠㅠ Mina, you can rest more ♥ It's already a brave step that you took in participating in the album production alone! Love you, Twibabies.

5. [+235, -38] Twice Mina jjang

6. [+83, -10] You're amazing enough already for participating in the album, I know that it took a lot of strength for you to do that

7. [+64, -3] It'd be weird if the kids never got sick after all the promos they've had to do.. I hope everyone recovers well..

8. [+120, -63] Twice feels like they're losing their energy. The typical decline of a top girl group... I thought they'd be able to maintain their status for longer than SNSD but it doesn't look easy.

-Source: Nate

1. [+421, -25] Red Velvet's problem: that they're getting weirder by the comeback
Twice's problem: that they're being overworked
Black Pink's problem: their agency
IZ*ONE's problem: that they're never in Korea
Lovely: is a problem
Oh My Girl's problem: that they're only getting popular now
Mamamoo's problem: their excessive fashion looks

2. [+165, -13] I guess she won't be participating in promos, just the song and MV recordings. It's true, meeting people is the hardest part...

3. [+142, -38] Out of all the idol groups this year, seems like none of them have had a hit song outside of BTS. Twice's 'Fancy' was #1 on Melon for a few hours before it disappeared and didn't get any reaction. The idol world feels so different now.

4. [+26, -8] At this point, isn't it better for Mina to just leave the group? If she keeps going like this, the members will always have to edit their songs and dances depending on when Mina is there or not. It's uncomfortable for everyone involved. It's not like they can wait forever and cater to her every whim. You can tell from the music video that she doesn't look well and people like her just bring the mood down for everyone else. She's unable to take care of herself and the problem remains that she's unable to participate in promos either. She should either halt her entire career or leave the group.

5. [+18, -9] Mina, don't be sick

6. [+15, -8] I just saw the new music video and Mina looks so depressed in it.. find strength ㅠㅠ

7. [+13, -6] Feels like Jihyo gets injured so often with every comeback

8. [+8, -5] Health comes first... just don't take on more than you can handle..

-

Article: JYP bans questions on Jihyo and Kang Daniel at Twice showcase "pass on questions about their private life"

Source: Newsen via Nate

1. [+338, -44] Well duh??

2. [+280, -36] It's rude to even be asking that stuff at their showcase

3. [+228, -36] Good move on JYP's part

4. [+31, -5] It is rude to even be asking such personal stuff at a comeback showcase. All questions should be related to the album. Why ask anything sensitive?...

5. [+30, -6] It's a showcase, only questions about the album or their performance should be allowed

6. [+8, -3] Not even that curious, honestly

7. [+6, -0] It's not like this is Jihyo's solo showcase, her private life is not something to bring up at a Twice showcase...

8. [+4, -0] Why would you ever expect more from Korean journalists

-

Article: Jihyo, sitting on a chair from stiff neck

Source: MK Sports via Nate

1. [+635, -37] She's the only decent singer so it's not like they can have her sit out like Mina. She can't even take a break because there's no other vocal in the group.

2. [+486, -51] Out of all the biggest agencies, JYP is the one who's working their groups like slaves these days. They don't have a money making male group aside from Got7, and it's obvious JYP's getting greedy for the Yen with their plans for an all Japanese group, tsk tsk tsk

3. [+479, -39] JYP used to be the one to call out slave contracts in the first generation but now they're the ones who are overworking their own artists. Seems like there's a member that's sick with every comeback.

4. [+39, -37] Recycle girl

5. [+29, -4] She's looking prettier since she's been dating

6. [+18, -4] ㅋㅋㅋㅋ The comments are all making a big deal out of how they're being overworked but they still have time for other things like shopping and dating ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

7. [+14, -3] Jihyo's beauty is at its peak these days... as they say, those in love get prettier~

8. [+12, -3] She looks like a doll

 

[Golden]

Jihyo has gotten so pretty

 

[eden]

4. [+31, -5] It is rude to even be asking such personal stuff at a comeback showcase. All questions should be related to the album. Why ask anything sensitive?...


PREACH

 

[Yukihime]

I hope Jihyo can make a fast recovery, she'll need total rest if she wants to recover fast though. Been there done that and thinking things like "if I take it easy it'll be fine..." ha. Nope, you'll end up forgetting your sore neck and make a harsh movement which will ruin any progress you might have done.
Anyway I hope it's just a small matter and that' she'll be fine in a few days.

It's good that Mina made the effort to participate but it's best for her to not force herself unless she's ready, and that comment about Mina... not worth commenting.

 

[JNT-LEGGO]

Both of these things are kinda common sense, especially the one about Daniel

 

[Tommie]

[+421, -25] Red Velvet's problem: that they're getting weirder by the comeback
Twice's problem: that they're being overworked
Black Pink's problem: their agency
IZ*ONE's problem: that they're never in Korea
Lovely: is a problem
Oh My Girl's problem: that they're only getting popular now
Mamamoo's problem: their excessive fashion looks

EXPLAIN.​

 

[ValerieKMY96]

Dragging someone for recycling is such a weird flex ma

 

[Whisky23]

Twice's problem is that certain times of the year, they get super busy. That's usually near the year end when awards, SK comeback and JP comeback/repackage tends to overlap. But people tend to forget that this year, they had two extended breaks where they all went on holidays, so this whole "enslaved by JYPE" thing is perplexing. Especially as they are not employees, and what they earn is based on their activities, not a fixed salary.

Girls don't have the luxury of having large female fandoms who will throw money at their idol "boyfriends". Like in the real world, they have to work 2x, 3x harder just to be at the same earning level as the some of the Top BGs. As tough as this idol life might be for them, why would anyone want to deny them the opportunity to make the kind of money that anyone else can only dream off?

Everyone seems to forget that the nugus that promote for 4+ weeks on music shows (long-ass hours), run back and forth to every shopping mall event just for an opportunity to make a name for themselves, and doing it while barely earning a cent (if any) and without receiving much love or acknowledgement from fans and the GP...those unknown idols are probably suffering the most right now.

Mina will come back when she's ready - non-fans need not bother themselves about what good for her or the group. The girls are more than capable of deciding for themselves. Much in the same way that Jihyo can decide whether she wants to help recycle glass bottles or not.

 

[emily]

what question about daniel could you even come up with lol

 

[Echo]

5. [+18, -9] Mina, don't be sick

How she gon control it wtf

 

[Whisky23]

what question about daniel could you even come up with lol

LOL. They'll probably ask her what brand soju KD drinks if they could. The problem is that SK is used to seeing celeb couples' life in the news, both good (Kangnam, Hyori) and bad (Goh Hye Sun), so I'm sure they'll find something to titillate their readers.

 

[autumn melancholy]

4. [+26, -8] At this point, isn't it better for Mina to just leave the group? If she keeps going like this, the members will always have to edit their songs and dances depending on when Mina is there or not. It's uncomfortable for everyone involved. It's not like they can wait forever and cater to her every whim. You can tell from the music video that she doesn't look well and people like her just bring the mood down for everyone else. She's unable to take care of herself and the problem remains that she's unable to participate in promos either. She should either halt her entire career or leave the group.

This dumbass has no clue how anxiety works at all.

 

[Stannie]

I can only hope that the girls will focus on the 99% that are supportive of them and not the 1% who don't.

 

[fullofjoy]

7. [+14, -3] Jihyo's beauty is at its peak these days... as they say, those in love get prettier

WOO! I NEED A MAN IN MY LIFE!!!

 

[Aegyo]

ugh this whole JYP is slaving twice ridiculous thing again....

 

[Lilac]

5. [+30, -6] It's a showcase, only questions about the album or their performance should be allowed

I agree.

 

[rising dawn]

Lovely: is a problem

I'm sorry, wtf are you saying about Lovelyz?

 

[rising dawn]

1. [+635, -37] She's the only decent singer so it's not like they can have her sit out like Mina. She can't even take a break because there's no other vocal in the group.

Nayeon(?*) didn't sing the whistle note in the B-side Rainbow for this goddamn slander

(?*) - IDK if it's really Nayeon who sang that whistle note in Rainbow or if it was just some sound effect that sounds like a whistle note but on /r/kpop some ONCEs were suggesting that it was Nayeon singing it and that it couldn't have been Jihyo because Jihyo was singing the main part.

 

[anaira]

8. [+120, -63] Twice feels like they're losing their energy. The typical decline of a top girl group... I thought they'd be able to maintain their status for longer than SNSD but it doesn't look easy.

 

[Misa]

Get well soon Mina