Who is the Beyonce of thanksgiving dinner?

[heather]

I keep seeing an ad about some guy saying the stuffing is the best? Like, first of all, isn't it dressing if you didn't make it in the turkey? And second of all -- get some help??

So for you who is best, darkhorse/slept on and worst?

My vote is:
Cornbread
Potato Salad
and the worst is that god awful turkey.

 

[hatmixx]

Pecan Pie be like....

 

[heather]

Pecan Pie be like....

To eat or for decoration?

 

[hatmixx]

for decoration?

in what world do you make a pie for decoration xD

 

[heather]

in what world do you make a pie for decoration xD

When it is pecan pie. This is a serious thread, hatmixx

(I'm joking ofc)

 

[Beefy]

Best: mac n cheese
Dark Horse: cranberry sauce ngl
Worst: any casserole (green bean specifically ) like there's a time and place for that

and turkey can defo be the worst depending on who cooks it

 

[hatmixx]

When it is pecan pie. This is a serious thread, hatmixx

(I'm joking ofc)

Joke's on you bc more pecan pie for me!

 

[heather]

Best: mac n cheese
Dark Horse: cranberry sauce ngl
Worst: any casserole (green bean specifically ) like there's a time and place for that

and turkey can defo be the worst depending on who cooks it

TTbh I don't understand casserole as a concept it feels like putting a Chinese buffet into a baking pan.

Joke's on you bc more pecan pie for me!

Without the ice cream?? Diabolical!

 

[hatmixx]

Without the ice cream?? Diabolical!

Never been an ice cream and pie person

Honestly, more than half of my family is vegan. And the rest of the family that we used to do Thanksgiving with has moved away or died. Thanksgiving has gone from my favorite family meal of the year to completely forgettable now. It's been years since I've had a real traditional Thanksgiving

 

[dnb]

best: roast beef (yes, my family makes it now for Thanksgiving due to popular demand)

dark horse: wine and margaritas

worst: turkey

 

[hatmixx]

best: roast beef (yes, my family makes it now for Thanksgiving due to popular demand)

dark horse: wine and margaritas

worst: turkey

You have the most ridiculous menu lol not saying I dislike it. Just not typical

 

[heather]

best: roast beef (yes, my family makes it now for Thanksgiving due to popular demand)

dark horse: wine and margaritas

worst: turkey

OHOHO I do pot roast these days too!!!

Never been an ice cream and pie person

Honestly, more than half of my family is vegan. And the rest of the family that we used to do Thanksgiving with has moved away or died. Thanksgiving has gone from my favorite family meal of the year to completely forgettable now. It's been years since I've had a real traditional Thanksgiving

Honestly, same (about it not being a thing anymore.) Like the faux history attached to Thanksgiving sucks but it is a good holiday. I definitely miss the full meals.

 

[dnb]

You have the most ridiculous menu lol not saying I dislike it. Just not typical

Yes, not typical, because the typical Thanksgiving dinner is really boring. No one in my family is a big fan of turkey.

 

[Chiharu]

my mom always makes carrot cake for thanksgiving (without raisins or nuts, thankfully), and for me, that is the highlight

 

[Seriously]

and the worst is that god awful turkey.

Turkey is just crap chicken, and I'll die on that hill. There's a reason it's seasonal.

But stuffing is ELITE, top tier, would devour in alarming quantities.

 

[RussianRoulette]

I’m Polish so for us it was the soup and pierogis

For my friend’s family, she hated turkey so they had a thanksgiving lasagna (we’re from NJ and tbh a thanksgiving lasagna is somewhat common here).