Mochiface

Nugu
Joined
Jul 1, 2019
Posts
119
Reaction score
107
Points
3,970
Location
France
Plus Coins
⨭43,100
Par Coin
0
People seem to think that just because Koeun and Lami were Rookies that they would 100% debut and they seem to forget that SM scouts new trainees every year who are just as talented, if not more. It doesn’t matter if you’ve trained for 1 year, 5 years or even 10 years, if you’re not right for the group, you’re not right for the group. Plus people kinda over exaggerated how talented the Rookies really were... people kept saying Koeun was a main vocal but her vocals were pretty subpar at best

No she wasn't a main vocal
But she wan't a sub vocal

She was at least lead vocal during MMC and we don't know how her vocal evolve after all these years where we didn't hear her
 

Yupuplover

Senpai Early Supporters
Joined
Jun 15, 2019
Posts
43,233
Reaction score
35,245
Points
84,220
Location
Singapore
Plus Coins
⨭22,728,328
Par Coin
436
People seem to think that just because Koeun and Lami were Rookies that they would 100% debut and they seem to forget that SM scouts new trainees every year who are just as talented, if not more. It doesn’t matter if you’ve trained for 1 year, 5 years or even 10 years, if you’re not right for the group, you’re not right for the group. Plus people kinda over exaggerated how talented the Rookies really were... people kept saying Koeun was a main vocal but her vocals were pretty subpar at best
Well, I'm not surprised. For myself, I never think Koeun and lami were rookies that they would 100% debut. Since I know about Lami around 2013, at that time , I was not 100% she would become an idol but I thought SM would do the same thing as they did before SNSD debut (i.e. how SNSD Yoona debuted, being an actress first). When koeun was introduced, I did see her talents and hope she would debut.

For now, I really just curious about the sm team handling for this new gg project. I do know that SM have artists that debuted with less than 1 yr trainees. I 'm curious about their standards now. Even when RV debuted, Lami was ever mentioned she will debut but that time her age was not fit to debut because she still a minor. I think Koeun too was also thought to join RV that time (p.s. i can't confirm these but I ever saw somewhere mentioned before). But she didn't. So some is now really curious the standards of these new gg since sm teams (i.e.staffs) are changing now.

P.s. just want to say, i'm not those people. Like I said in previous page, i stop follow sm rookies girls after being played by SM in the past. So now, i came back because they literally confirmed 2-3 or more times via their report & media. Though indeed i'm sad, both Koeun and lami left since they were my biases since 2013 for lami & 2015 for Koeun, I still wonder the new gg since is been a long time SM debut a ngg and I want to see the new concept SM going to create since SM is well-known by the gp for creating new concept
 
Last edited:

sacute18

Lurker
Joined
Mar 17, 2020
Posts
9
Reaction score
2
Points
1,020
Plus Coins
⨭4,700
Par Coin
0
During 2015, I believe koeun, herin, Hina and lami were the top trainees along with some hidden trainees, but I believe sm must have found newer and better trainees over the last few years.
 

Yupuplover

Senpai Early Supporters
Joined
Jun 15, 2019
Posts
43,233
Reaction score
35,245
Points
84,220
Location
Singapore
Plus Coins
⨭22,728,328
Par Coin
436
During 2015, I believe koeun, herin, Hina and lami were the top trainees along with some hidden trainees, but I believe sm must have found newer and better trainees over the last few years.
Yes, which i believe. That is why I'm curious about these hidden trainees as there are very little information about them unlike previously how SM did this "rookies" thing project then abandoned it. Never like showcase in SMTown family like they did in the past. Not even letting them attend their artist concerts, where last time some ever appeared on SM artists' concert. is like too silent.
 

SwolMingyu

☾ #1 Meanie Stan ☾ Donor
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
352
Reaction score
406
Points
5,920
Location
Canada
Plus Coins
⨭199,740
Par Coin
0
This better be about the girls or I’m jammed getting the foot with these cryptic a** messages
I feel like given SM just debuted such a large scale boy group in NCT, they wouldn't be debuting another. So the big group is probably the girls

large & ace
same info as this acc?

We're getting close, I can feel it!
 

yerm

I can make the beat go! Graphics Lead Donor
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
2,443
Reaction score
2,692
Points
47,770
Plus Coins
⨭2,505,806
Par Coin
0
Pronouns
she/her
Instiz premium I think you either have to pay for a code or get someone else with an account to send you a code but then, yeah, you need a Korean phone number :(

Happy Kouen day guys!
 

Wewantmoregirls

Ya better work bish
Joined
Sep 26, 2019
Posts
148
Reaction score
58
Points
3,870
Plus Coins
⨭45,300
Par Coin
0
No she wasn't a main vocal
But she wan't a sub vocal

She was at least lead vocal during MMC and we don't know how her vocal evolve after all these years where we didn't hear her
Koeun had a really nice voice tho and she was pretty and can dance and has stage presence lami was the one who was more normal than anything
 

Bellamy

Happy Holidays〰 VIP+ Early Supporters Second Place HoE
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
59,764
Reaction score
23,059
Points
105,120
Plus Coins
⨭40,322,264
Par Coin
1,260
Pronouns
She/Her
...ok but talking about the visuals and talent of Koeun and Lami...when SM barely gave us something....:eek:hnah:

We just need to wait the official announcement... most likely they'll debut at mid-late may or early june.
At this point, the lineup is fixed so let just wait for the teasers.
 

AstroBaby

Trainee
Joined
Jun 30, 2019
Posts
822
Reaction score
957
Points
6,220
Location
United States
Plus Coins
⨭520,400
Par Coin
0
ik it's ancient news at this point but I still don't get what the following and then unfollowing of Lami's account by ex-trainees was about..ppl were saying it's because she's still in SM just as an actress (which wasn't too surprising to me since she'd originally joined as an actress, didn't participate on shining star, went to a non-performance school, etc.) but since SM clearly let her open the account wouldn't she just be the same as sm artist at that point? like Herin can follow Yeri without a issue and if she doesn't want/isn't allowed to associate w ex-trainees why post a pic w Koeun? idk man that whole week was wild...
 

Bellamy

Happy Holidays〰 VIP+ Early Supporters Second Place HoE
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
59,764
Reaction score
23,059
Points
105,120
Plus Coins
⨭40,322,264
Par Coin
1,260
Pronouns
She/Her
ik it's ancient news at this point but I still don't get what the following and then unfollowing of Lami's account by ex-trainees was about..ppl were saying it's because she's still in SM just as an actress (which wasn't too surprising to me since she'd originally joined as an actress, didn't participate on shining star, went to a non-performance school, etc.) but since SM clearly let her open the account wouldn't she just be the same as sm artist at that point? like Herin can follow Yeri without a issue and if she doesn't want/isn't allowed to associate w ex-trainees why post a pic w Koeun? idk man that whole week was wild...

Maybe they aren't that close anymore...or the fact that Lami didn't follow them back...?
...the simplest explanation is almost always the correct one...
 

Yupuplover

Senpai Early Supporters
Joined
Jun 15, 2019
Posts
43,233
Reaction score
35,245
Points
84,220
Location
Singapore
Plus Coins
⨭22,728,328
Par Coin
436
So... has anyone seen if that “instiz premium” thing was true or kfans trolling us?
Hmm I think the issue is not whether is it a troll or true anot. The issue is will those who have those photos, willing to leak out on other sns. Because I saw one smngg stan on twitter, asking people not to leak as it will spoil the "spazz" of their promotion. Also, I'm not sure whether are there any kfans like that smngg twitter stan, asking that OP to take down as they also don't want people to leak out
 

Vintaege

Cornucopia of useless informations
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Posts
239
Reaction score
264
Points
3,970
Location
Planet earth
Plus Coins
⨭111,740
Par Coin
0
ik it's ancient news at this point but I still don't get what the following and then unfollowing of Lami's account by ex-trainees was about..ppl were saying it's because she's still in SM just as an actress (which wasn't too surprising to me since she'd originally joined as an actress, didn't participate on shining star, went to a non-performance school, etc.) but since SM clearly let her open the account wouldn't she just be the same as sm artist at that point? like Herin can follow Yeri without a issue and if she doesn't want/isn't allowed to associate w ex-trainees why post a pic w Koeun? idk man that whole week was wild...
SAME! And the weirdest thing is Herin didn't wish her this year but she used to all the the year.....did something happen? Or this really isn't Lami? Don't know I'm so confused
 
Top Bottom