Last Team Standing: Girl Groups Edition

[Saint Ren]

Anticipating Hwa and Seraphim sending the exact same covers

 

[Andrea]

Dahlia and Hwa made their choices.

 

[Yuki]

i thought it would be all RV

 

[Mimi]

 

[Some]

Hwa Fighting my pretty flowers

 

[Andrea]

Seraphim submitting 2 minutes before deadline.

 

[peach]

Good luck everybody!

 

[DR. K💉M 👄]

Fashionably late you know

 

[Andrea]

It feels good to have a second judge (@Baymax).
We will both give a separate vote to each selection, the only exception is that Baymax won't judge his team.

 

[Andrea]

Round 2: "Album Covers: Simply Colorful" Results

Wendy (Hwa) - 4 points
ALBUM COVER 1 - ALBUM COVER 2
Momo (VESI) - 3,7 points
ALBUM COVER 1 - ALBUM COVER 2

Seohyun (Dahlia) - 2,5 points
Irene (Seraphim) - 2,5 points

Main post updated!

Round 3 - High Notes​

Instructions: One idol from each team will send me 1 fancam following the main theme.

Ineligible: Wendy (Hwa) - Momo (VESI)

Submissions: 1
Eliminations: 3

Challenge: Singing
Theme: High Notes
Deadline: 24 hours

Prize: Winning team will be able to choose next round's challenge.

Judges: @Andrea - @BlueNose (2nd judge) - @SomethingThere (3rd judge)
Note: Fancams must be taken from the idol's performance with her girl group.

Tags:
@Kimbo @BlueNose @Dove @OutroTearTheFirst @peach
@SomethingThere @Saint Renjun @softest_bun @Seagull.. The Great @miatheikonic
@Aquamaraqua @boo @Yuki @AKID❀KI @Ombré
@WithJuyeon @Chiharu @Baymax @mocha @Dr. Satan

 

[BlueNose]

are members with elimiated idols still able to talk in the team PM?

 

[Some]

We woooooooon yaaaaay

 

[Sweetheart]

Miss mocha and bluwu, i'm SO sorry ​

 

[peach]

​

Note: Fancams must be taken from the idol's performance with her girl group.

 

[DR. K💉M 👄]

can i know what the criteria was for this?
we thought if happiness makes such a big difference from rookie, we'd at least get to learn how the scoring is working

but then the twice albums are exactly like rookie
how did we still score with that big of a difference?

 

[Andrea]

are members with elimiated idols still able to talk in the team PM?

Yes and they can still help their team, it'a team after all and winning the game is the goal.

I just read you saved solo performances, haha. Time for some changes!

can i know what the criteria was for this?
we thought if happiness makes such a big difference from rookie, we'd at least get to learn how the scoring is working

but then the twice albums are exactly like rookie
how did we still score with that big of a difference?

Many things were taken into account while voting but with Rookie, honestly, it's quite simple to explain for me. Sure it is colorful but the challenge doesn't mean matching only the theme, in this case it had to be colorful but I also expected a nice outlook (covers serve that purpose after all), instead I found it being messy and weird. Comparing Page Two with Rookie when the only thing is common is that cyan color is not fair.

 

[Chiharu]

Yes and they can still help their team, it'a team after all and winning the game is the goal.

I just read you saved solo performances, haha. Time for some changes!

Many things were taken into account while voting but with Rookie, honestly, it's quite simple to explain for me. Sure it is colorful but the challenge doesn't mean matching only the theme, in this case it had to be colorful but I also expected a nice outlook (covers serve that purpose after all), instead I found it being messy and weird. Comparing Page Two with Rookie when the only thing is common is that cyan color is not fair.

How is rookie weird but not happiness....I guess it's just personal preference

 

[DR. K💉M 👄]

Yes and they can still help their team, it'a team after all and winning the game is the goal.

I just read you saved solo performances, haha. Time for some changes!

Many things were taken into account while voting but with Rookie, honestly, it's quite simple to explain for me. Sure it is colorful but the challenge doesn't mean matching only the theme, in this case it had to be colorful but I also expected a nice outlook (covers serve that purpose after all), instead I found it being messy and weird. Comparing Page Two with Rookie when the only thing is common is that cyan color is not fair.

Messy? Is that why happiness got such a high score? It's super colourful but has the messiest outlook(which is fine if you liked messy). We picked rookie over happiness to see whether you were marking in terms of outlook or colorful mostly. And looking at your top score, it definitely looks like colourful>>outlook.

But then suddenly Page two (which is cyan based mostly and pretty plain otherwise) gets a higher score. You said it has to stand out in your explanation, but nothing quite makes it stand out from the other submissions. That's exactly what im asking ? What was the criteria you were going for that puts a simple photo album cover above others, while at the same time putting a messy but colourful one at the top?

 

[Andrea]

Messy? Is that why happiness got such a high score? It's super colourful but has the messiest outlook(which is fine if you liked messy). We picked rookie over happiness to see whether you were marking in terms of outlook or colorful mostly. And looking at your top score, it definitely looks like colourful>>outlook.

But then suddenly Page two (which is cyan based mostly and pretty plain otherwise) gets a higher score. You said it has to stand out in your explanation, but nothing quite makes it stand out from the other submissions. That's exactly what im asking ? What was the criteria you were going for that puts a simple photo album cover above others, while at the same time putting a messy but colourful one at the top?

I already explained the criterias and I don't agree when you say that Happiness has "the messiest outlook" because the first thing you can notice, just by giving it a quick glance, is how each idol is perfectly occupying one corner and then there's a specific setting in the center (logo, column, ect.). Rookie, instead,has adopted a copy and paste idea that I find ugly and really unappealing to watch. Lastly, Page Two is the kind of cover I'd gladly make a poster of.

 

[DR. K💉M 👄]

I already explained the criterias and I don't agree when you say that Happiness has "the messiest outlook" because the first thing you can notice, just by giving it a quick glance, is how each idol is perfectly occupying one corner and then there's a specific setting in the center (logo, column, ect.). Rookie, instead,has adopted a copy and paste idea that I find ugly and really unappealing to watch. Lastly, Page Two is the kind of cover I'd gladly make a poster of.

You wrote album art in your explanations
Both of twice covers were just photographs.

You're pretty much telling us the criteria are whatever you will like. It will be almost impossible for us to tell whether you'll find something most people find messy, messy or not. Or that you think putting things at the edges make something less messy.

This is pretty biased and its not even low key starting with the specific theme of the round itself. Count me out.