The scores have all been given and calculated.
I will now give the results,
before I announce the scores,
here are some comments from one of the judges @cheesebun for each pair~
@Chomiczewska and
@Bchip
The DPs are very pretty, but I feel like a lot more could have been done with the borders of the heart, as they look a bit plain in the sig.
@Saint Renjun and
@Bot
I'm actually shocked that you guys pulled this together. I think its cool, and something no one else would have done. I love the meaning, and I love how it reflects on both of you. In terms of execution, I think you guys could have done a bit more (filters etc), but otherwise the aesthetic of it is there.
@Baymax and
@Chiharu
I love how much this reflects you guys. I think it is so cute and sweet that is handdrawn and I have to reward that. You guys did an awesome job, and I think it is gorgeous. The only thing I would improve on is the DP. It doesn't convey the beauty of the sig.
@outrotear and
@Nara
I see where you two were going, but I was not crazy about the quality of the gifs and the color scheme. These are two separate sigs that anyone could have had any time of year. I just don't see the link.
@sm maid and
@Turtle
I think this is a super cute concept! My only real issue is that this was such an overplayed concept after Palette was released, and I think the sig could have been a tad but cleaner. I think it is very pretty, though.
@AKID❀KI and
@Yuna
This is very pretty. Aki knows my weakness is CoupsHan. My only issue is that this is quite a bit oversaturated as well as a contrast that kind of loses the image. The paper just doesn't standout, though it is very inventive and pretty. I think it would be a good idea to work on the structure of this to make it a bit more pleasing to the eyes.
@Beefy and
@miatheikonic
I love the bakery concept, I think it is very cute. I think the valentines spirit is totally there, and it just... its just so perfect in that regard. I absolutely appreciate this level of creativity. However, aesthetic is where it suffers a bit. The sig could use some work in terms of smoothness, for example, maybe having those images on a wrapper around the cookie or some candies would have pulled it together more. I also would have like to see more with the DP. Maybe an analog filter?
@Dr. Nugu and
@boo
Listen, listen, you guys know I love any aesthetic and I actually like this. I think you could have actually executed this so well with the coke and pepsi bottle. I think condiments and soft drinks are a great direction to go with aesthetic this year, so I can show a great amount of appreciation for it. I think the sig is also very pretty.
For everyone:
Overall, please pay close attention to the quality of the images you are using, Also, make sure when you are editing an image, you are actually improving it. Some images need a lot more TLC than others. Otherwise, some beautiful sets in here!