GFX [Feedback Needed] Minnie Hann Case Design

[Aquamaraqua]

So I decided to design my own iPhone 7 Plus (black silicone) phonecase, and this concept is based on Minnie in Hann by (G)I-DLE. Minnie is a Scorpio, and Hann has a motif of a scorpion, so I wanted to include both the constellation and the animal.

My issue is that with the animal included, it ends up looking clunky no matter the color/placement, so I was wondering if I should just forego the scorpion itself. The only issue is I feel like the scorpion is such an iconic part of Hann... but alas.

Let me know which design looks better:

No Scorpion

Scorpion 1

Scorpion 2

Scorpion 3

If you have any other feedback like coloring etc. please let me know!​

 

[Dragon of the West]

Scorpion 2

​

I personally like this one the most because the placement of the scorpion works best in this though a small suggestion I'd make would be for the scorpion to be white with some black detailing. These all look pretty good though!

 

[OutroTearTheFirst]

If you want the scorpion go for it
I personally like the ones where the scorpion is lower in the moon​

 

[Riri]

it's pretty! i think last one is the best one

 

[anh]

i like number 2

 

[abra]

I like 2 and 3 the most. But I prefer the scorpion black (or white with black outline, as DotW suggested) over gray

 

[ARandomFan]

2 or 3! With the comments everyone else has made...

and this is a personal thing for me but i think the scorpion would look better bigger? Not super big but just enough to where it’s more noticeable

 

[Some]

I dont understand art but i love scorpian 2