Official (G)I-DLE Badge Voting Thread - FINISHED!

[liv]

Here's our feedback for Soojin, Yuqi, and Shuhua:

(G)I-DLE Part 2

Needs fixing: → needs recoloring (she’s too pale); i’d also push her to the left a bit more, since there’s too much bg there → needs to be pushed to the left a bit & maybe zoomed in? → needs recoloring & she’s a bit off center → needs major recoloring, she’s a ghost → needs recoloring ...

docs.google.com

@Siobhan Halo @liv

No set deadline for right now, but please let me know your plans as soon as possible.

You can either:
1) fix them yourself (I recommend getting feedback in the Ask the Awards Team thread before re-submitting if you're unsure)
2) take the original photos to the Request a Mock Badge thread and have an AT member help (please make sure to follow the thread's rules)
or
3) let me know if you wish to have any of your suggestions discarded​

Please remove my suggestions that need to be fixed, my favorite mocks are good to go fortunately

 

[tokki]

Please remove my suggestions that need to be fixed, my favorite mocks are good to go fortunately

noted

 

[Siobhan Halo]

Mocks rejigged
Original > Adjusted

>

Soojin is super pale in the original picture, prob can't be saved for a badge.

>

or

>

>

>

>

 

[tokki]

i submitted the fixed mocks, just waiting to see what the AT lead says about them~

 

[tokki]

Alright, here's what the AT lead said about the fixed mocks:

(G)I-DLE pt 2

-> she’s too grey -> still too pale and slightly off center -> LQ, there’s noise all over and slightly off center -> her face is still paper white -> looks lq, weird coloring OK:

docs.google.com

@Siobhan Halo

---

I'm just going to discard this suggestion of mine since unfortunately, I don't think it can be fixed any further and I've already spent hours trying to improve it with not much luck.

 

[tokki]

Okay, so - after the discarded mocks, we were down to 0 suggestions for Soojin, 1 for Yuqi, and and 4 for Shuhua. The AT managed to try and save one Soojin mock somewhat, so we will be able to hold a vote for her in the end.

So what we will do is this:
- we are skipping straight to the final voting round for all three members due to the small amount of suggestions
- for Soojin and Yuqi, there will obviously only be a yes or no vote since they have 1 suggestion each; should YES win, that will become the member's final badge - should NO win, suggestions will be-reopened for that member for a few days
- Shuhua's voting will be done just the same as any other final vote

I'll try to get everything set up so that we can start voting tomorrow.

 

[tokki]

final voting for soojin, yuqi, and shuhua
ends september 17th at 11:59pm EST

Like I explained earlier, after removing the mocks that users requested to be discarded, we're left with only 1 suggestion for Soojin (after the AT worked to fix a previous one) and 1 for Yuqi, so their vote will be either a yes or a no. If yes wins, that will become the member's final badge; if no wins, then we will re-open suggestions at the end and go from there.

Since this is the final voting round for these members, please vote for only one mock for Shuhua!

VOTING FORM
Username:
Keeping (out of Soojin, Yuqi, and Shuhua):

Are you happy with this as Soojin's final badge? (yes or no):
Are you happy with this as Yuqi's final badge? (yes or no):
Shuhua (vote for only one mock):

----

tagging users who were previously interested in keeping or supporting any of these members in case they'd like to vote:
@Siobhan Halo @Keodi @Mina @liv @Po'etry @Rektinq @ByulHarangBona @Remukū @Aquamaraqua @miatheikonic @yooamygirls @BlueNose​

 

[yooamygirls]

Username: yooamygirls
Keeping (out of Soojin, Yuqi, and Shuhua): Soojin

Are you happy with this as Soojin's final badge? (yes or no): Yes
Are you happy with this as Yuqi's final badge? (yes or no): Yes
Shuhua (vote for only one mock): 3

 

[fromisJelly]

Username: ByulHarangBona
Keeping: Soojin, Yuqi, Shuhua

Soojin: yes
Yuqi: yes
Shuhua: 3

 

[Tommie]

Username: Keodi
Keeping (out of Soojin, Yuqi, and Shuhua): Soojin

Are you happy with this as Soojin's final badge? (yes or no): Yes
Are you happy with this as Yuqi's final badge? (yes or no): Yes
Shuhua (vote for only one mock): 3​

 

[BlueNose]

Username: bluenose
Keeping (out of Soojin, Yuqi, and Shuhua): yuqi

Are you happy with this as Soojin's final badge? (yes or no): yes
Are you happy with this as Yuqi's final badge? (yes or no): yes
Shuhua (vote for only one mock): 3

 

[yoongles]

can i vote even though I'm new here? I won't be able to keep until I have enough posts

Username: yoongles
Keeping (out of Soojin, Yuqi, and Shuhua): N/A

Are you happy with this as Soojin's final badge? (yes or no): Yes
Are you happy with this as Yuqi's final badge? (yes or no): Yes
Shuhua (vote for only one mock): 3

 

[tokki]

can i vote even though I'm new here? I won't be able to keep until I have enough posts

Username: yoongles
Keeping (out of Soojin, Yuqi, and Shuhua): N/A

Are you happy with this as Soojin's final badge? (yes or no): Yes
Are you happy with this as Yuqi's final badge? (yes or no): Yes
Shuhua (vote for only one mock): 3

yup, anyone is allowed to vote! keepers just receive double votes

 

[Yeddong]

Username: Remukū
Keeping (out of Soojin, Yuqi, and Shuhua): None

Are you happy with this as Soojin's final badge? Yes!
Are you happy with this as Yuqi's final badge? Yes!
Shuhua: #03

 

[Mina]

Username: Mina
Keeping (out of Soojin, Yuqi, and Shuhua): None

Are you happy with this as Soojin's final badge? Yes
Are you happy with this as Yuqi's final badge? Yes
Shuhua: 3

 

[rektinq]

Username: Rektinq
Keeping (out of Soojin, Yuqi, and Shuhua): All 3

Are you happy with this as Soojin's final badge? (yes or no): Yes
Are you happy with this as Yuqi's final badge? (yes or no): Yes
Shuhua (vote for only one mock): 3

 

[miatheikonic]

Username: Miatheikonic
Keeping: None

Are you happy with this as Soojin's final badge?: Yes
Are you happy with this as Yuqi's final badge?: yes
Shuhua: 2

 

[tokki]

Username: jin
Keeping (out of Soojin, Yuqi, and Shuhua): Yuqi

Are you happy with this as Soojin's final badge? (yes or no): yes
Are you happy with this as Yuqi's final badge? (yes or no): yes
Shuhua (vote for only one mock): 3

 

[mocha]

Username: mocha
Keeping (out of Soojin, Yuqi, and Shuhua): none

Are you happy with this as Soojin's final badge? (yes or no): yes
Are you happy with this as Yuqi's final badge? (yes or no): yes
Shuhua (vote for only one mock): 3

 

[Aquamaraqua]

Not to be that person but I think this could be a wonderful Yuqi badge

Is it too late to submit?