TWICE BADGES - DISCUSSION AND VOTING - MEMBER BADGES - COMPLETED

[Whisky23]

I hope you wildcarders realize, that you risk losing your favorite winning badge

Can we exclude badges from the voting if many voters voiced dislike for it? Or not?

My only requirement for wildcards is that it be limited to 1, max 2 wildcards per member, and only be limited to new content. The opportunity to propose older content has passed. You will need to exclude badges if there are too many, obviously, but if it fits in the '1, max 2' limit, then voting is the main way of expressing dislike. Also, if people do vote for a wildcard round, then we'll have to draw the line somewhere and not repropose another vote after every new content drops, else we'll never get badges.

 

[Stannie]

I hope you wildcarders realize, that you risk losing your favorite winning badge

Wdym. Are doing wildcard for all or just the ones where ppl vote for wildcard

 

[Stannie]

Ok I just read first post. Apparently for all

Risking 6 to save 3. To do or not to do

 

[sexy cutie]

Ok I just read first post. Apparently for all

Risking 6 to save 3. To do or not to do

reminder that the ones voting are the same old people....

 

[Stannie]

reminder that the ones voting are the same old people....

That's my worry. They might make it worse I only really want change for TzuNaMi but besides Nayeon, I can't really find new material for MiTzu.

Can we sneak in Oh boy! back in for wildcard? I'm sure whiskey won't notice

 

[sexy cutie]

we should've just voted the whole oh boy set tbh

 

[Jihyo StoleMyHeartAYAYAY]

Voted.

 

[TBJ]

Im pretty content overall so Im personally fine the way it is but looks like we're in for more

 

[Whisky23]

It's still early days before the poll closes, but those who are in the wildcard camp should start lining up their wildcard badges. Ideally, y'all should sort out which badge you'd want before the poll closes, so that we can move quickly into the wildcard vote. Maybe you guys can post the badges you propose for which member, and we can collate it all and discuss.

 

[A Flower4ever]

@whisky23

I like all badges samples for wilcards that @Monessa shared.

My pick for a Jeongyeon wildcard is this one:

 

[Whisky23]

My guess about why the Oh Boy sets didn't win was because (1) the backgrounds were white, and (2) the expressions were more serious. It also didn't help that some badges are already used on other forums. Colorful, smiley badges or colorful, glamorous badges tend to win.

So far, we have's Jeongyeon's wildcard officially proposed.

 

[twiceeejihyoooo]

Wait so wildcards need to be for all members? It's too much of a risk.

 

[Whisky23]

Wait so wildcards need to be for all members? It's too much of a risk.

If we open a wildcard round, then technically it should be open for all members.

 

[B612]

If we open a wildcard round, then technically it should be open for all members.

not really, wildcard is only for those that people generally agree that will benefit from it

and most members badges are great as they are

I also agree on the Jeongyeon badge

 

[Whisky23]

not really, wildcard is only for those that people generally agree that will benefit from it

and most members badges are great as they are

I also agree on the Jeongyeon badge

My point is that anyone can propose wildcard badges for any members in a wildcard round. As for people agreeing or disagreeing, for me as long as it's doesn't break the "1, max 2" limit, you might as well use the wildcard poll to decide whether people agree or disagree. Otherwise, technically we will need to poll EACH wildcard badge being proposed, and that for me is too tiresome.

 

[Mina]

Well, I'm throwing this into the discussion. Or does anyone have a better badge for Mina?

The Year of Yes-one in the voting can also work!

 

[montchery]

Well, I'm throwing this into the discussion. Or does anyone have a better badge for Mina?

The Year of Yes-one in the voting can also work!

This is the prettiest out of the last 3 she got for the final round imo
But can it compete in the wildcard round or do the wildcard suggestions need to be completely new? (I read the OP but it only says ideally it should be something new.. so idk if that means we can or cant)

 

[Mina]

This is the prettiest out of the last 3 she got for the final round imo
But can it compete in the wildcard round or do the wildcard suggestions need to be completely new?

Off you're right. Wildcard rounds tend to only work with completely new material.
RIP to the best Mina badge

 

[montchery]

Off you're right. Wildcard rounds tend to only work with completely new material.
RIP to the best Mina badge

right, i dont understand how this didnt win.. I wish we could use it again or have it as an alternative badge but I think that's only for groups

 

[Stannie]

I'm voting for no wild card just because I have trust issue with MiTzu anti squad and I'm generally happy with the other members' badges

But if we do wildcard, this is my Tzuyu suggestion:

cr: B612