EXO playlist contest: December 3rd - December 10th

[Mina]

Please remember that you have to send me a pm with your playlist before deadline!

There's two days left but please don't wait out til the last minute ​

 

[Mina]

A little more than 48 hours to go!​

 

[Vampire]

Please remember that you have to send me a pm with your playlist before deadline!

There's two days left but please don't wait out til the last minute ​

A little more than 48 hours to go!​

sent mine! sorry for not doing it sooner - been busier than anticipated

 

[Mina]

About 24 hours until deadline!

Please send your playlists to me before that or your submissions won't count.
Deadline is Tuesday 23:59 GMT+1 (Wednesday 7:59AM KST).
​

 

[Evanescence]

https://hallyuplus.net/threads/exos-xiumin.19167/

 

[BlueNose]

@Mina i told u i would donate for the game, but i forgot until just now. so i donated some sorry

 

[Mina]

About 12 hours left!​

 

[Mina]

@Mina i told u i would donate for the game, but i forgot until just now. so i donated some sorry

thank you blue

 

[BlueNose]

finally finished my playlist sdfghjkl

 

[miatheikonic]

APPRECIATION - Chen best stage ever

"This thread was made to enter the "EXO Playlist Contest" game - Click here to participate!"

hallyuplus.net

 

[Mina]

The game has ended!

I will send the playlists to the judges as soon as possible. I will @ all participants when the result is finished.
Thank you all for playing!

 

[Mina]

The results will come out tomorrow December 27th!!
​

 

[Mina]

@Aeri_Panda @Saint Renjun @Vampire @Evanescence @BlueNose @fullofjoy @yooamygirls @miatheikonic

The results will be announced in less than 3 minutes.

My co-judges @Vivi @Galaxy @Dove @Lucia listened to all playlists "anonymously" in a judges PM to avoid any bias.
Judges will actually discover who sent what today!

I'll post all playlists gradually with all comments from judges.
It wasn't mandatory for judges to comment on all playlists for every player, but we tried to do it as much as possible.

To keep things interesting, I'll reveal the scores and winners at the end

No comment was written to "bash" any player, we really appreciated everyone's efforts.
So please don't take any offense in case you'll read sounds "bad".

This was simply a game made to have fun, promote Exo a little on the forum and celebrate their comeback.
Among the participants, there were fellow Exols, but also non-fans and I hope the latter category discovered songs they like!

As your host, I would like to say a huge thank you to everyone who participated. This was the first game I hosted and it was so much fun
​

 

[BlueNose]

me knowing i sent ballads and dove being a ballad h8er
its over for me

also sorry dove, ofc the playlist game ur judge for is the one that i wrote to explain my choices lmfaoo

 

[Galaxy]

Now I want to know who sent what Good luck everyone, judging this contest was definitely interesting and I had as much fun as usual

(Please don't hate me, players )

 

[Mina]

User 1 - @fullofjoy

Playlist 1









Playlist 2









Playlist 3










Judge 1
Playlist 1: Ending their evolution at White Noise doesn't seem right to me, their sound has changed a lot since it
Playlist 2: Overdose will always be a bop, the other two.. well
Playlist 3: Overdose is already in the previous playlist which is against the rules, only Universe has anything to do with H+ and even with it I can't really feel the connection

Judge 2
Playlist 1: Your songs were very fitting but I would've loved to see the years ''spread out'' more; you just covered three years in Exo's musical evolution so I would have liked to see something more recent.
Playlist 2: -
Playlist 3: I loved your picks and your descriptions were nice, but I had to give you zero points because you repeated a song which is against the rules.

Judge 3
Playlist 1: "Machine" was a great choice to start your playlist, however I don't really think that "My Lady" really represents EXO's sound whatever the chosen era is, and "White Noise" would have been a perfect choice for your 2nd song instead of finishing your playlist with it.
Playlist 2: "Overdose" is one of their best bops, "Touch it" is one of their best b-sides, and although I wouldn't especially put "Baby Don't Cry" in there, it makes the whole thing varied, so I enjoyed your playlist.
Playlist 3: Sorry for the bad score, but the rules stated that you can't use songs twice.

Judge 4
Playlist 1: There is definitely a clear change of sound and genre in the songs that you've chosen so wonderful job on that! However, my only complaint is that I wish you could have chosen a song that represented EXO's sound in the middle of their careers rather than chosing My Lady and chosen a song from current EXO as we know them now (like a song from Obsession or DMUMT) rather than ending the playlist with White Noise. To me, that would have further shown EXO's musical evolution.
Playlist 2: I absolutely love all of your choices. Each of the songs have a completely different vibe from each other. Overdose is more hard hitting while Touch It has more of a funky vibe to it and Baby Don't Cry is just a fantastic ballad song. It isn't boring and keeps your ears from falling asleep. However, Touch It is the only song that doesn't stick with me.
Playlist 3: You didn't quite explain why the first two songs represented your H+ experience. I wish you maybe could have elaborated as to why you choose Baby You Are and Overdose for playlist 3. However, with Universe you perfectly explained why you picked this song and why it reminded you of H+. Great job on that! However, I do have to give you no points because you used Overdose twice which is against the rules. I'm sorry!

Judge 5
Playlist 1: This is tough since I am not feeling this as a good evolution. Maybe if you had swapped your 2nd and 3rd.
Playlist 2: Overdose is a bop! As for the other 2 I feel there were better choices but still not bad at all.
Playlist 3: This is really sad since you broke the rules I can't give you a score.​

 

[moon_ravn]

Good luck to everyone

 

[Panda]

This is quite nerve wracking

 

[Mina]

User 2 - @yooamygirls

Playlist 1









Playlist 2










Playlist 3










Judge 1
Playlist 1: -
Playlist 2: I don't really like or dislike any of these songs, they're just... there
Playlist 3: Overdose as a song doesn't really fit here

Judge 2
Playlist 1: A perfect playlist to show Exo's evolution.
Playlist 2: You saying Lotto is your favorite Exo song gave away your identity, that's how rare your opinion is lmfao. I liked the songs!
Playlist 3: -

Judge 3
Playlist 1: I would have chosen something else to represent EXO's debut, but as a whole I do see the evolution I wanted to see!
Playlist 2: Ahh, "Lotto"... the song that could have been very good without all that autotune, sigh. You made me discover "Playboy" and I like it. As for "Christmas Day", you're lucky I'm feeling the Christmas spirit right now, because it's really not among my favorite EXO songs!
Playlist 3: I'm not sure I understand the choice of "Overdose". You managed to link "Gravity" with your experience on H+, so good job. I found the addition of "Baby, Don't Cry" very thoughtful.

Judge 4
Playlist 1: Absolutely wonderful job at showing EXO's musical evolution! However, I have to say that I would not have included a ballad with two upbeat songs. I would have chosen a upbeat song from early EXO instead to make it more consistent but nonetheless fantastic job!
Playlist 2: All I gotta say is that you have TASTE including Lotto because that song is a bop and a half. It's weird with Playboy because it has that sound that I love and has those little harmonies that make the song feel like smooth chocolate but I just don't feel it.
Playlist 3: Your explanations of why you chose certain songs that represented your H+ to you was wonderful to read and not gonna lie I was tearing up when reading the explanation of Baby Don't Cry

Judge 5
Playlist 1: A good selection of songs for this playlist, they really show just how their sound changed through the years. Loses only a bit on that first songs since its not only a ballad but also sang by only a few members.
Playlist 2: It would have been perfect if the Christmas song chosen was a different one since that is not one I find all that good, for the rest good choices!
Playlist 3: Like everyone else said Overdose really doesn't fit here.

​

 

[BlueNose]

This is quite nerve wracking

ikr? im scared​