TWICE BADGES - DISCUSSION AND VOTING - MEMBER BADGES - COMPLETED

[sexy cutie]

BTW since this is the FINAL final voting for members, I propose that each member’s keeper(s) gets a double vote​

 

[Whisky23]

BTW since this is the FINAL final voting for members, I propose that each member’s keeper(s) gets a double vote​

1 person, 1 vote. ​

 

[sexy cutie]

1 person, 1 vote. ​

Everyone else is doing it i just want to avoid another situation where the member’s stans are not happy



also tbh as jeongyeon’s keeper i just want to keep the one i really like

 

[Whisky23]

Everyone else is doing it

I should have known that member badges would get messier.

 

[sexy cutie]

PM me if someone wants easy 10k plus coins
​

 

[Whisky23]

PM me if someone wants easy 10k plus coins​

​

 

[B612]

Nayeon's winner badge is perfect why are you all trying to ruin things only to regret later just like y'all did with Mina's TWICE2 that lost

have some taste for ONCE (pun intended)

 

[AshithBangera]

BTW since this is the FINAL final voting for members, I propose that each member’s keeper(s) gets a double vote​

I agree with this, i have seen other groups doing this. Input of the ones who are keeping the badge should be more important than some non-fans vote​

 

[Monessa]

I do agree that Nayeon’s winning badge is already good. I only had problems with MiTzu’s winners to begin with but I have made peace with it now. Member badges are so brutal. Can we still withdraw the wildcard suggestion for Nayeon?

 

[A Flower4ever]

I am keeping the winning badge for Jeongyeon, while I don't claim I'm have owning rights to her image, I do want the best of them all.

 

[Whisky23]

I agree with this, i have seen other groups doing this. Input of the ones who are keeping the badge should be more important than some non-fans vote​

But right now, we don't have a complete list of people who intend to keep the badges. So unless you intend to go through the whole process first of identifying everyone who will keep which badge, then I don't see how you'll be able to allocate the extra votes. The blame the loss of a particular badge to non-fans is a bit unfair since Onces also voted for badges that people didn't like or want.

I do agree that Nayeon’s winning badge is already good. I only had problems with MiTzu’s winners to begin with but I have made peace with it now. Member badges are so brutal. Can we still withdraw the wildcard suggestion for Nayeon?

It's been proposed, so it will have to go through the system. I'm putting a pre-vote up to see which members should get a wildcard poll - you can make your opinions known through that poll.

I am keeping the winning badge for Jeongyeon, while I don't claim I'm have owning rights to her image, I do want the best of them all.

Exactly. Even though not all of us will keep a particular member's badge, we all want what we think is the best for each member.

 

[AshithBangera]

But right now, we don't have a complete list of people who intend to keep the badges. So unless you intend to go through the whole process first of identifying everyone who will keep which badge, then I don't see how you'll be able to allocate the extra votes. The blame the loss of a particular badge to non-fans is a bit unfair since Onces also voted for badges that people didn't like or want.


It's been proposed, so it will have to go through the system. I'm putting a pre-vote up to see which members should get a wildcard poll - you can make your opinions known through that poll.


Exactly. Even though not all of us will keep a particular member's badge, we all want what we think is the best for each member.

Somehow you make it sound like we want worst for each member. We are coming up with these solutions to get the best for each member. Nobody is claiming the members pic as their own​

 

[sexy cutie]

Exactly. Even though not all of us will keep a particular member's badge, we all want what we think is the best for each member.

I mean i personally find this badge weird-looking

But the Tzuyu stans love it tho so there must be something in it that only Tzuyu stans can see

 

[Whisky23]

Somehow you make it sound like we want worst for each member. We are coming up with these solutions to get the best for each member. Nobody is claiming the members pic as their own​

But the solutions you're proposing it to put the opinions of one group (keepers) over others. I'm not saying you want the worst for each member, but what I am saying is that you're skewing the vote closer to your preferences. As you can see, we have a lot of varied opinions of what is good and what is not - the only fair way to resolve this is to give everyone equal vote.

I mean i personally find this badge weird-looking

But the Tzuyu stans love it tho so there must be something in it that only Tzuyu stans can see

I personally agree. But as much as I respect the opinions of Tzuyu stans, I feel that as an OT9, my opinions on her badge is equally valid. But if it's put to a vote and this badge wins, so be it.

 

[AshithBangera]

But the solutions you're proposing it to put the opinions of one group (keepers) over others. I'm not saying you want the worst for each member, but what I am saying is that you're skewing the vote closer to your preferences. As you can see, we have a lot of varied opinions of what is good and what is not - the only fair way to resolve this is to give everyone equal vote.


I personally agree. But as much as I respect the opinions of Tzuyu stans, I feel that as an OT9, my opinions on her badge is equally valid. But if it's put to a vote and this badge wins, so be it.

in the end i will keep every single badge no matter which pic is selected, so do as you see fit​

 

[A Flower4ever]

Somehow you make it sound like we want worst for each member. We are coming up with these solutions to get the best for each member. Nobody is claiming the members pic as their own​

"We are coming up with these solutions to get the best for each member."

That's the intention of everyone here, is just that we express ourselves differently, so at the end is working towards that goal.

 

[Whisky23]

TWICE MEMBER BADGES - WILDCARD ROUND YES OR NO?

The saga continues. We have a new poll to decide whether to proceed with a wildcard round for a particular member. Please refer to Post #1 and #2 in deciding your choices.

There is a light at the end of this tunnel. Stay on target.

TWICE BADGES - DISCUSSION AND VOTING - MEMBER BADGES - COMPLETED

Hi folks, it's time to decide on the Twice badges that we want for Hallyu+. The purpose of this thread is for people to share badges for consideration, which we will then vote for submission to the Hallyu+ team. __________________________________________________________________________________...

hallyuplus.net

MEMBER BADGES - APPROVED WILDCARD CANDIDATES

MEMBER BADGES - CURRENT BADGE WINNERS

 

[sexy cutie]

idk if it will happen but what do we do in case of a tie? i think we need to clarify that now

 

[Whisky23]

idk if it will happen but what do we do in case of a tie? i think we need to clarify that now

If it's a tie, then technically it did not win the majority to proceed to wildcard runoff.

 

[Stannie]

Nayeon has two wildcard badges, so she and Tzuyu have will need a runoff.

As for @B612 , turns out she wasn't able to connect to the internet for the past few days. Not only wasn't she able to respond to your requests for input, but turns out she had some suggestions of her own. Sigh..

Since Bee is the main Twice badge designer plus awards team member, I'll give a pass for her late badge submissions due to her connection issues.

@meltrosz yeah, I noticed it wasn't on @AStan summary post which I based my submission off. Quickly message @B612 that nylon badge since she's prepping her badge submissions and approvals. But sorry, I'm not taking submissions from anyone else since everyone else was online.

I removed the Nylon because @Mina suggested that one and they were fine with "surrendering" it to reduce down the options.