TWICE BADGES - DISCUSSION AND VOTING - MEMBER BADGES - COMPLETED

[sexy cutie]

Current wildcard badges being proposed (pending approval from @B612):

@Mina @AStan @Monessa , you'll need to work out which 2 from these will go into the wildcard round. If you can't, then I'll need to conduct a separate poll beforehand just to pick the Top2.

i vote 1 and 2. for tzuyu tho....

 

[Monessa]

I don’t know why people don’t like these Tzuyu badges.
What’s the opinion of other Tzuyu stans? Am I the only one here?

 

[Stannie]

I don’t know why people don’t like these Tzuyu badges.
What’s the opinion of other Tzuyu stans? Am I the only one here?

I'm here And I love and prefer this Tzuyu badge over the winning one:

Not sure what's awkward about it. She looks gorgeous af here

 

[DR. K💉M 👄]

Hi, I'm confused whether a wild card is going on
I wanted to suggest this momo badge but I didn't follow this thread so not sure if it was suggested
sorry if it was

x

 

[sexy cutie]

I don’t know why people don’t like these Tzuyu badges.
What’s the opinion of other Tzuyu stans? Am I the only one here?

don't you find this weird-looking

I'm here And I love and prefer this Tzuyu badge over the winning one:

Not sure what's awkward about it. She looks gorgeous af here

it looks like her face is stiff with botox or smth

 

[Stannie]

it looks like her face is stiff with botox or smth

What even.

or

 

[sexy cutie]

What even.

or

lmao it's just so stiff and shiny

 

[Monessa]

You guys can’t appreciate high fashion aesthetics.

 

[DR. K💉M 👄]

tzuyu 2 and 3 are pretty

 

[Whisky23]

Hi, I'm confused whether a wild card is going on
I wanted to suggest this momo badge but I didn't follow this thread so not sure if it was suggested
sorry if it was

x

Yes, we are in the middle of accepting wildcard suggestions. However, we are only accepting suggestions from new image sets (since the initial polling). I believe this image from an earlier photo set. But thanks for the suggestion, though. We'll definitely keep for the next round, whenever that will be.

 

[sexy cutie]

tbh i'm fine with the winning tzuyu badge but i want to save her from the wildcards
x

x

---
now here are my wildcard suggestions

x

x

x

i like the Nayeon & Jeongyeon wilds suggested so these are all for my suggestions

 

[peach]

Please think really, really careful what badges you suggest for the wildcard round and if you really, really think the badges you suggest are actually better than the current winning badge.
I don't know how often it happened that people suggested all kind of pictures, but none were an actual improvement (since the best pictures are usually already suggested during the first suggestion phase.
Later everyone is unhappy bc a not so great wildcard wins and then everyone realizes that the original winning badge wasn't so bad, but then it's too late.

Just my two cents, hehe.

 

[sexy cutie]

Please think really, really careful what badges you suggest for the wildcard round and if you really, really think the badges you suggest are actually better than the current winning badge.
I don't know how often it happened that people suggested all kind of pictures, but none were an actual improvement (since the best pictures are usually already suggested during the first suggestion phase.
Later everyone is unhappy bc a not so great wildcard wins and then everyone realizes that the original winning badge wasn't so bad, but then it's too late.

Just my two cents, hehe.

i like the ones i suggested

 

[Whisky23]

Please also ensure that you have HD sources for the badges you propose, as you'll need those to get approval as well. Again, it's fine for everyone to submit badges, but if we have more than 2 wildcard badges for a member, you'll either need to decide which of the badges you'll choose for the final wildcard vote, or we'll have to poll for it.

Edit: It's looking likely that we may end up having to poll to choose which wildcards will go into the final vote. If that is the case, then polling will choose only one wildcard per member for the final wildcard vote.

 

[Mina]

The first wildcard for Nayeon, I like her face but the angle is giving me a sore neck. Thoughts? @Mina

Well, I like the badge but I like all wildcard suggestions for Nayeon so I can surrender to #2 and #3!

I don’t know why people don’t like these Tzuyu badges.
What’s the opinion of other Tzuyu stans? Am I the only one here?

Ngl I love that badge!

 

[peach]

i like the ones i suggested

They are not bad, but too LQ, since they are screenshots.
And you can see the blurred person in Tzuyu‘s badge

 

[Whisky23]

I'll submit your badges for pre-approval, but I suspect quite a few of them won't make the cut.

 

[Whisky23]

Are these ok to use as far as quality is concerned? @B612

Since B612 hasn't replied to your post, my suggestion is to go ahead and make the badges. I'll be submitting all the proposed wildcard badges for pre-approval, so if it doesn't pass there, it doesn't pass. Frankly, we avoided at the BT images simply because of the color hues weren't ideal, and were generally unflattering to their skin tone. But if you wish to propose them, go ahead and make the badge mockups and hope they get approved.

 

[Stannie]

So I've decided to not fix what's not broken and withdraw my suggestions for Dahyun & Chaeng @whisky23 . I like the shots but they have good winning badges already.

Edit:

At this rate, I'll just display other members' instead of MiTzu's even tho they are my biases

 

[Whisky23]

At this rate, I'll just display other members' instead of MiTzu's even tho they are my biases

Your self-sacrifice will be remembered.