☆♡ The Official NMIXX Thread! | "Fe3O4: STICK OUT" 2024.08.19 ♡☆

지우____ · Dec 25, 2019

itzy said:
Exactly. I don't want them to be a big group just because they have a lot of trainees. Every company has a lot of trainees, it doesn't mean they have to debut as many of them as they possibly can at once. If I was to make the group 6-7 members I'd say Rima, Haewon, Hayul, Jiayu, Lily, Yunjin + Yuna if 7

The thing is that a lot of trainees weren’t extremely charismatic. Yuna and Jia Yu didn’t got a lot of positive feedback. And the only ones who got positive feedbacks were Haewon, Rima, Miihi and Lily M.

a smalL groups needs to have all the members to be full of charms and stage presence. One member slacking will be extremely obvious. + all the members should be talented/good in the dancing, Singing, Rapping category. One member that isn’t as talented as the others will get the most hate.

a bigger Group doesn’t need that. all the members don’t need to be charismatic, Talented. Hence why there are “Filler” members aka the visual members. A filler member in a 4-7 member group is extremely much more obvious then in an 7+ group.

itzy · Dec 25, 2019

지우____ said:
The thing is that a lot of trainees weren’t extremely charismatic. Yuna and Jia Yu didn’t got a lot of positive feedback. And the only ones who got positive feedbacks were Haewon, Rima, Miihi and Lily M.

a smalL groups needs to have all the members to be full of charms and stage presence. One member slacking will be extremely obvious. + all the members should be talented/good in the dancing, Singing, Rapping category. One member that isn’t as talented as the others will get the most hate.

a bigger Group doesn’t need that. all the members don’t need to be charismatic, Talented. Hence why there are “Filler” members aka the visual members. A filler member in a 4-7 member group is extremely much more obvious then in an 7+ group.

Itzy’s Yuna got literally 0 positive feedback from the showcases besides her being pretty and she’s one of the most charismatic and talented rookies in Kpop so I’m not going to base my picks solely on the opinions of others

지우____ · Dec 25, 2019

itzy said:
Itzy’s Yuna got literally 0 positive feedback from the showcases besides her being pretty and she’s one of the most charismatic and talented rookies in Kpop so I’m not going to base my picks solely on the opinions of others

ITZY Yuna neither got Negative feedback. And there was smt that everyone saw in her which was her charisma. And yeah it is true, it’s your own opinion at the end of the day. But it doesn’t mean that it will eventually be true. The current trainees aren’t strong enough to be in a small group

itzy · Dec 25, 2019

지우____ said:
ITZY Yuna neither got Negative feedback. And there was smt that everyone saw in her which was her charisma. And yeah it is true, it’s your own opinion at the end of the day. But it doesn’t mean that it will eventually be true. The current trainees aren’t strong enough to be in a small group

"There're plenty of criticism on Yuna so I felt kinda odd. From my point of view, the top visuals were Yuna and Ryujin today... First of all, she has big eyes and small face. And her features are distinct.
Honestly, if we have to find someone who's in charge of Tzuyu's role in the this next batch of trainees, I'd say it's Yuna. She's tall, and has a nice body ratio. I think she's just receiving criticism as she's at a young age and is still growing up."

Yuna was criticised a lot. A lot of fans didn't want her in Itzy because they thought she would've added nothing to the group besides visuals.

Wewantmoregirls · Dec 25, 2019

itzy said:
Eh idk I’d prefer them to be smaller. Smaller groups are more appealing to me plus I feel like they can be just as successful with 4 members then they could with 9 or more

Bcuz twice isn’t the #1 gg...bcuz snsd wasn’t the #1...

Wewantmoregirls · Dec 25, 2019

itzy said:
Probably not. Survival shows have lost their popularity over the years and with the Produce scandal I doubt any broadcasting channel would make any survival shows for the time being. Plus also Mnet worked on both Sixteen and Stray Kids and they said they’d never do survival shows again

I wouldn’t say that just no other survival show did as well as produce even during the survival show hype but queendom proved survival didn’t lose its touch just you need the right audience to reach and the right platoform

itzy · Dec 25, 2019

Wewantmoregirls said:
Bcuz twice isn’t the #1 gg...bcuz snsd wasn’t the #1...

They were popular because they had hit songs like Gee and Cheer Up, not because they specifically had 9 members

itzy · Dec 25, 2019

Honestly at this rate idc how big the group is as long as Jiayu and Haewon get to debut that’s all that matters to me

지우____ · Dec 25, 2019

itzy said:
Honestly at this rate idc how big the group is as long as Jiayu and Haewon get to debut that’s all that matters to me

De you can have your own opinion!

AstroBaby · Dec 25, 2019

지우____ said:
The thing is that a lot of trainees weren’t extremely charismatic. Yuna and Jia Yu didn’t got a lot of positive feedback. And the only ones who got positive feedbacks were Haewon, Rima, Miihi and Lily M.

where did you see Miihi getting super positive feedback? Everything I saw said she was cute + had potential but that it was obvious she hadn't trained long...Yunjin also got a ton of praise for her stage presence + dance (although her singing needs to improve) and was the only trainee to have a solo stage apart from Lily. And while Jiayu hasn't gotten a ton of praise apart from her visuals we already know she's an great dancer from her predebut videos and she's been training since 2016 and featured in every showcase (which is only for girls already likely to debut) so clearly JYP sees something in her even if the showcase audience doesn't

AstroBaby · Dec 25, 2019

itzy said:
"There're plenty of criticism on Yuna so I felt kinda odd. From my point of view, the top visuals were Yuna and Ryujin today... First of all, she has big eyes and small face. And her features are distinct.
Honestly, if we have to find someone who's in charge of Tzuyu's role in the this next batch of trainees, I'd say it's Yuna. She's tall, and has a nice body ratio. I think she's just receiving criticism as she's at a young age and is still growing up."

Yuna was criticised a lot. A lot of fans didn't want her in Itzy because they thought she would've added nothing to the group besides visuals.

Yeah as someone who followed what is now Itzy since 2017 a lot of people hated Yuna and wanted Haewon, Lily, or Jiayu to take her place

지우____ · Dec 25, 2019

AstroBaby said:
where did you see Miihi getting super positive feedback? Everything I saw said she was cute + had potential but that it was obvious she hadn't trained long...Yunjin also got a ton of praise for her stage presence + dance (although her singing needs to improve) and was the only trainee to have a solo stage apart from Lily. And while Jiayu hasn't gotten a ton of praise apart from her visuals we already know she's an great dancer from her predebut videos and she's been training since 2016 and featured in every showcase (which is only for girls already likely to debut) so clearly JYP sees something in her even if the showcase audience doesn't

Read my comment again: I never said that those girls got “super Positive” feedback. I ONLY said that the girls got positive feedback. Miihi got positive feedback for her Visuals and Charisma. I never mentioned ANYTHING a about her talent.

itzy · Dec 25, 2019

Honestly, I don't think fans feedback from the showcases are worth using as reasoning as to why certain trainees should or shouldn't debut. Before Stray Kids (the show), no one really included Yeji in their ideal lineups because fans that saw her at the showcases left little to the imagination at the time, but as soon as the episode aired, everyone fell in love with her and wanted her to be in the group. The same could easily be said for one of the current trainees. There might be one that's not really popular because not much is mentioned of them from the showcases, but they become well-liked when revealed on a show or something of that nature.

지우____ · Dec 25, 2019

itzy said:
Honestly, I don't think fans feedback from the showcases are worth using as reasoning as to why certain trainees should or shouldn't debut. Before Stray Kids (the show), no one really included Yeji in their ideal lineups because fans that saw her at the showcases left little to the imagination at the time, but as soon as the episode aired, everyone fell in love with her and wanted her to be in the group. The same could easily be said for one of the current trainees. There might be one that's not really popular, but is well-liked when revealed on a show or something of that nature.

Oh yeah I totally forgot about that. The same happened to Rhujin before she joined mix9.

AstroBaby · Dec 25, 2019

지우____ said:
Read my comment again: I never said that those girls got “super Positive” feedback. I ONLY said that the girls got positive feedback. Miihi got positive feedback for her Visuals and Charisma. I never mentioned ANYTHING a about her talent.

ok I guess I assumed since you listed her alongside Haewon, Lily, and Rima who have basically been praised as goddesses that you were saying she got similar feedback, sorry

itzy · Dec 26, 2019

Honestly the most praised trainees are Haewon, Lily, Rima, Mako & Minji. Haewon for her visuals and vocals, Lily for her vocals, Rima for her visuals, Mako & Minji for their dancing.

itzy · Dec 26, 2019

Jiayu has left JYP no

I wanted her to debut so badly. She has Instagram and Facebook now

Sana Akgae · Dec 26, 2019

itzy said:
Jiayu has left JYP no I wanted her to debut so badly. She has Instagram and Facebook now

Is this confirmed? Anyway, she may be joining Produce China like Ningning.

itzy · Dec 26, 2019

Sana Akgae said:
Is this confirmed? Anyway, she may be joining Produce China like Ningning.

I found her on Facebook. Looks as though she’s back in Taiwan or China so idk but it’s definitely her. It looks a lot like her just Kpopified lol. I’m so sad though! Hopefully she can join a new company soon

Sana Akgae · Dec 26, 2019

itzy said:
I found her on Facebook. Looks as though she’s back in Taiwan or China so idk but it’s definitely her. It looks a lot like her just Kpopified lol. I’m so sad though! Hopefully she can join a new company soon

It means JYPE has neither Chinese nor a Taiwanese female trainee left?