Ask the Awards Team

[perspherspley]

Username: perspherspley
Name of Award: MinKkura Badge ~ IZ*ONE
Type of Award: Award Request Form
Voting Thread: https://hallyuplus.net/threads/iz-o...adge-voting-thread-open-for-suggestions.7353/

 

[crazykuroneko]

The first one just looks too edited now, honestly, I'd just scrap it.
The second one looks okay but now that I look at the third, it needs to be either zoomed out a bit or pushed up - his chin is almost touching the edge of the badge. It looks slightly LQ as well, maybe if you could give me the original picture I could try fixing it?

And something I didn't notice earlier - they all have bad corners! They should be 20px for Photoshop and 40px for Photoscape.

sorry, I made those with online editor.

I just remade them all on Photoshop like you said:

here is link to all the source images ❤

 

[BlueNose]

hi, I was told this badge was too light

but a friend of mine made it a bit dimmer

is this this 2nd badge ok to suggest? if not can someone help me out? this is the original pic if needed

 

[boo]

Hi, can you tell me if these badges are ok? or needs improvement?

Thank you!

 

[liv]

Hi there! Are these mocks okay?

Original pictures: x x x

 

[Mina]

Could you please tell me if these badges are now ok when I tried to improve them? I am also wondering if I need to put these up for pre-approval again

--->

(Needed recoloring and sharpening)

--->

(Too dark, needed recoloring)

--->

(Recolored)

--->

(Too bright)

--->

(Needed recoloring and brightness)

 

[moon_ravn]

sorry, I made those with online editor.

I just remade them all on Photoshop like you said:

here is link to all the source images ❤

They looks better now! you can go ahead and suggest those.

hi, I was told this badge was too light

but a friend of mine made it a bit dimmer

is this this 2nd badge ok to suggest? if not can someone help me out? this is the original pic if needed

Pretty sure someone PM'ed Galaxy in the meantime so I'll skip this one.

Hi there! Are these mocks okay?

Original pictures: x x x

The first one could be a bit brighter on the face.

The second one is way too dark overall, she's on a shade it looks like? so yeah needs some editing.

The third one I'd try and correct that lighting on her right side of the face?

 

[moon_ravn]

Hi, can you tell me if these badges are ok? or needs improvement?

Thank you!

3rd one and 5th ones need some light fixing, poor things are looking very pale ghost there.

Last one also is a bit too light over all between the bg and clothes and light on the face!

 

[boo]

3rd one and 5th ones need some light fixing, poor things are looking very pale ghost there.

Last one also is a bit too light over all between the bg and clothes and light on the face!

Thanks for letting me know! I tried fixing them. let me know if they are still too light.

 

[Sweetheart]

Hi!
Is an editing round needed if the badges that won were edited by the awards team themselves?
​

 

[boomimo]

There's a chance to rename Ten/Win-win/Lucas/Hendery/Yangyang as WayV and not Nct ?

 

[moon_ravn]

Thanks for letting me know! I tried fixing them. let me know if they are still too light.

They look better now yes!

Hi!
Is an editing round needed if the badges that won were edited by the awards team themselves?
​

No, editing rounds are made by users or the OP of threads, we can help ofc if we are asked but we have no direct involvement unless they are not within guidelines.

There's a chance to rename Ten/Win-win/Lucas/Hendery/Yangyang as WayV and not Nct ?

I'm sorry but no, they are all part of the NCT project. WayV is not an isolated SM group, they are a subunit and so can't have their own category.

 

[moon_ravn]

Could you please tell me if these badges are now ok when I tried to improve them? I am also wondering if I need to put these up for pre-approval again

Oh sorry I seem to have skipped yours but it wasn't on purpose Tbh I still see some problems so I'll fix them as best as I can for you so you can just move on!

 

[Mina]

Oh sorry I seem to have skipped yours but it wasn't on purpose Tbh I still see some problems so I'll fix them as best as I can for you so you can just move on!

View attachment 858 View attachment 859 View attachment 860 View attachment 861 View attachment 863

omg thank you, you're the best

can i just continue with the voting process now, i don't need to put them up for pre-approval again?

 

[moon_ravn]

omg thank you, you're the best

can i just continue with the voting process now, i don't need to put them up for pre-approval again?

If the approval needed are only these ones and the rest were approved before-hand you can go ahead!

If there are others that you have not pre-approved you need to get them approved first.

 

[Yukihime]

Hello ! Sorry for the bother. Before submitting them I wanted to be sure if those mocks were okay or on what I should work on please (when I added a or b options it's because I don't know which "brightness" is better).

1a.

(or 1b.

) - 2.

3.

4.

- 5a.

(or 5b.

) - 6.

-7.

-8.

9.

- 10.

- 11.

- 12.

 

[Some]

Can someone buy an award request form an another person does the thread is that okay ?

 

[moon_ravn]

Hello ! Sorry for the bother. Before submitting them I wanted to be sure if those mocks were okay or on what I should work on please (when I added a or b options it's because I don't know which "brightness" is better).

1a.

(or 1b.

) - 2.

3.

4.

- 5a.

(or 5b.

) - 6.

-7.

-8.

9.

- 10.

- 11.

- 12.

Let me go by numbers here then.

- 1a is better than 1b
- 2 needs a bit more brightness and I'll colour correct it slightly less warm too.
- 3 I would try and tilt the face a bit more to get it straighter and zoom in a tiny bit
- 4 looks LQ for me and also would zoom in a bit
- 5 looks not centered to me, a good rule of thumb is when the head is more in a profile position to center it with the eye in the middle. as for the version I'd say more 5a and less 5b.
- 6 again I would zoom in and looks like it needs some sharpen
- 7 needs colour correcting and it's too dark rn
- 8 and 9 are fine
- 10 I would fix that lighting on her hair really
- 11 and 12 same with colour correcting a bit less warmer and for 11 also too dark

Sorry for all the nitpicking

Can someone buy an award request form an another person does the thread is that okay ?

Yes, as long as someone has the form and they agree to let someone else use it, anyone can buy it and OP can be someone else!

 

[Mina]

Want to check if these are ok

Well I tried but I don't think they got any better lmao

 

[Yukihime]

Let me go by numbers here then.

- 1a is better than 1b
- 2 needs a bit more brightness and I'll colour correct it slightly less warm too.
- 3 I would try and tilt the face a bit more to get it straighter and zoom in a tiny bit
- 4 looks LQ for me and also would zoom in a bit
- 5 looks not centered to me, a good rule of thumb is when the head is more in a profile position to center it with the eye in the middle. as for the version I'd say more 5a and less 5b.
- 6 again I would zoom in and looks like it needs some sharpen
- 7 needs colour correcting and it's too dark rn
- 8 and 9 are fine
- 10 I would fix that lighting on her hair really
- 11 and 12 same with colour correcting a bit less warmer and for 11 also too dark

Sorry for all the nitpicking

ooof didn't expect to have to edit 80% of them Don't worry about it.
I knew the coloring for 2,7,11 and 12, but ugh it's a pain to get it right, as it's the "theme" of the photoshoot/comeback teasers so as soon as I tried to edit them it went towards the magenta
Anyway I'll try my best and pray that it won't get rejected during the approval (don't worry I won't ask you to review them all again, I'll avoid being that much of a pain )

Thanks for the review/advices.